News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Winklevoss syndrome by InclinedPlane on Friday February 18, 2011 @06:11AM (#2235033)
Ideas aren't entirely worthless, but execution is so significant that it can kill a good idea or rescue a bad idea.

Consider what would be necessary to fully detail an idea so completely as to make it difficult to screw up the execution. You would need to provide a lot of material to fill in all the details, thousands of words perhaps.

Consider an example of this: the adaptation of books to movies. Books are ideas that are enormously thoroughly detailed, far more detailed than the vast majority of ideas in business. And yet, what is the success rate of the translation of good ideas (in book form) to good movies? It's pretty spotty, and utterly dependent on good execution. How many excellent books have been executed as mediocre or horrible movies?

Good ideas can help (some of the best movies ever have come from books, for example), but they can just as easily be a length of rope from which to hang oneself.

There are no comments on this comment yet.