News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by ars on Thursday February 17, 2011 @08:37PM (#2233792)
Despite how it looks the yellow paddle wheel is not actually at the start of the track. The rectangular box at the start is not connected to the actual start of the track. It's far away from it, and it holds the yellow wheel and a bucket to catch water.

Next, ignore the beams, and focus only on the water track. Despite looking like it's climbing up, it's actually totally flat (i.e. you could make it from one sheet of wood). But tilted slightly so water flows from the start to the end.

Additionally the entire structure is not actually sitting on the garage floor, but rather is high up in the air, and the camera angle obscures this.

Hidden under the structure is a pump and an outlet at the true start of the track.

He pours water into the catch basin at the end of the track, and that same moment someone else starts the pump. If you watch closely you can see how it looks like the water he pours is being "swallowed", and does not actually flow down the track.

The water from the pump flows down the track, and out the spigot over the wheel and into the bucket.

Next you place beams carefully cut at angles to make them look like they are holding the track - but actually they are open on top.

But this is a pretty amazing piece of work.

Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by biot on Thursday February 17, 2011 @09:20PM (#2233932)
When he walked towards the camera at the end, I was really hoping he would change the perspective to reveal the illusion.
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by dasil003 on Thursday February 17, 2011 @11:54PM (#2234277)
It pissed me off when they did that in Inception. The whole point was that should be possible in a dream.
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by afterburner on Friday February 18, 2011 @01:00AM (#2234425)
But it was; the walking worked, despite how it looked.
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by dasil003 on Friday February 18, 2011 @02:20AM (#2234606)
Right up until the camera panned. Suspension of disbelief shattered, and to what end?
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by PakG1 on Friday February 18, 2011 @03:29AM (#2234746)
Are you kidding? If they didn't do that, how would they demonstrate a trap that made any sense? That would have been far worse, I think.
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by dasil003 on Friday February 18, 2011 @03:54AM (#2234797)
Yeah maybe I totally forgot what actually happened, I just remembered my irritation :)
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by jinfiesto on Friday February 18, 2011 @11:43AM (#2236108)
I was more irritated by the fact that the entire movie was clearly ripped from the chapter "Harmonic Labyrinth" from GEB.
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by InclinedPlane on Thursday February 17, 2011 @09:14PM (#2233914)
http://imgur.com/NE3Ax

The apparatus is not connected at the red line in this image. The part to the left (the wheel) is on the ground and farther away, the part to the right (the start of the track) is in the air and closer. They just happen to line up due to forced perspective.

The water just seeps down into a hidden reservoir in the left part, and is pumped up at the appropriate time from another reservoir in the right part.

Edit: see below, it looks like the discontinuity is at a different point.

Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by KeithMajhor on Thursday February 17, 2011 @09:26PM (#2233954)
http://imgur.com/z2FU8

It looks like, given the reflection from the water, that section of the track can't be more than an inch above the floor. If thats true then wouldn't the break have to be somewhere after that point?

If I'm missing some huge detail can someone explain it to me?

Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by InclinedPlane on Thursday February 17, 2011 @10:12PM (#2234065)
I think you might be right. The high-def version makes it easier to see where shadows fall. It looks like it's the back section that's separate from the rest. If you watch the high-def closely it looks very much like the first 3 segments of the track are behind the last segment (notice how his shadow passes over the last segment THEN the first 3 segments):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0v2xnl6LwJE#t=33s

http://imgur.com/c1Plc

Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by KeithMajhor on Thursday February 17, 2011 @10:51PM (#2234150)
Ya, if you watch it carefully you can see it burp a few times when the water moves past that post.

EDIT: I made a diff in GIMP of the shadow. It looks like both the top and bottom left facing ledges are connected. Notice the hard edges between the adjacent pillars.

http://imgur.com/zd25x

Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by jbri on Thursday February 17, 2011 @09:40PM (#2233991)
It looks to me like the break is at the first bend - on the HD version, the water coming in doesn't appear to turn a corner there at all, and then on the other side of the tower support it's flowing straight outwards.
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by KeithMajhor on Friday February 18, 2011 @12:26AM (#2234349)
I thought that too but there is a very convincing shadow on either side of that pillar.

http://imgur.com/FIVwu

Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by InclinedPlane on Friday February 18, 2011 @01:33AM (#2234505)
Excellent. Notice that the same shadow is missing on the last part of the track, at least in the part to the left of the vertical pillar.

Edit: http://i.imgur.com/Kqgtr.jpg

Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by ars on Thursday February 17, 2011 @10:54PM (#2234159)
That may be the legs that are holding the whole thing off of the floor.
Re:Real Life Model of M.C. Escher’s “Waterfall” by KeithMajhor on Thursday February 17, 2011 @11:19PM (#2234206)
The legs would have to be mounted in such a way that they were hidden by the structure. So they'd have to be at an angle and those in the reflection appear to be vertical.