Re:Astronomers want public funds for intelligent life search
by ekianjo on Saturday February 15, 2020 @09:54AM
(#22335636)
> High risk with the highest reward. What could fundamentally change humanity more than definitively finding intelligent life out there?
That's kind of ridiculous when you look at the odds. It's like saying playing the lottery every single day is a good investment because it's potentially high reward when in fact you are just basically fooling yourself.
There is probably close to zero chances that there is any kind of intelligent life living in our proximity (i.e. anything that could be reachable by human means), and even if there is any kind of life out there, what do we do with it if we can't travel there and directly observe it? Also, the reason the odds are against it is that galaxies are violent places and the Earth has been lucky to have been relatively stable climate for a very long time, enabling the development of life. I would bet that Earth-like planets may have the seeds for life elsewhere but get routinely massively disrupted in some fashion by external factors.
In any case, resources are limited, and there's sufficient abundance of projects with more tangible real-world applications that will be prioritized for good reasons.
> Three Body Problem by Cixin Liu
Science-Fiction is just that: Fiction. I hope we don't make investments or bets based on fantasy novels.
That's kind of ridiculous when you look at the odds. It's like saying playing the lottery every single day is a good investment because it's potentially high reward when in fact you are just basically fooling yourself.
There is probably close to zero chances that there is any kind of intelligent life living in our proximity (i.e. anything that could be reachable by human means), and even if there is any kind of life out there, what do we do with it if we can't travel there and directly observe it? Also, the reason the odds are against it is that galaxies are violent places and the Earth has been lucky to have been relatively stable climate for a very long time, enabling the development of life. I would bet that Earth-like planets may have the seeds for life elsewhere but get routinely massively disrupted in some fashion by external factors.
In any case, resources are limited, and there's sufficient abundance of projects with more tangible real-world applications that will be prioritized for good reasons.
> Three Body Problem by Cixin Liu
Science-Fiction is just that: Fiction. I hope we don't make investments or bets based on fantasy novels.