News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Government Shuts Down 84,000 Websites, ‘By Mistake’ by joe_the_user on Thursday February 17, 2011 @04:41PM (#2232990)
forgive my pedantry, but I'm not sure that having illegal property seized in a civil proceeding counts as punishment.

Well, when talking of doubtful distinction in argument, some may pedantry, others might say sophistry. If I say "I never touched him!" (but rubber hose did a fine job on his kidney), which am I engaging in?

More seriously, how the frickin heck can taking someone's stuff not be punishment? Moreover, given that this is a broad power, the existence of some instance where one can argue isn't punishment doesn't mean that there aren't many, many other instances where it is.

But some things are illegal to possess and thus subject to forfeit in the first place.

Note that civil forfeiture was not historically created or used for taking drugs themselves or other "illegal property". If someone has drugs, you can arrest them for possession and take the drugs as evidence. If you drop the charges, they could come to collect, except they won't since they'll be arrested for possession so you can dispose of the stuff (not that I'm particular in favor of drug laws but that's a different story). Civil forfeiture is for taking money and "instrumentalities".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset_forfeiture

"Asset forfeiture is confiscation, by the State, of assets which are either (a) the alleged proceeds of crime or (b) the alleged instrumentalities of crime..."

IE, it's not used for "illegal property" as such. And the addresses in this discussion certainly aren't "illegal property".

There are no comments on this comment yet.