News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by Stormbringer on Thursday February 17, 2011 @11:53AM (#2231625)
Sorry, but you're wrong. The iTunes DRM was ridiculously easy to circumvent even in iTunes itself. No mad leet hackzor skillz required.

Since you could trivially turn aac files into mp3 files in iTunes your quote:

"Sure you were free to get ANY other mp3 player in the world, as long as you were ok with losing all your music"

Is completely wrong. I can only assume you are one of the vast throngs of Apple haters who hate Apple and their products because it is trendy to hate trendy things.

I know the iPad supports pdf format, and I think also the epub format(?), which I believe is the big open standard that everyone 'should' be supporting? How is that bad evil and wrong? Apple has great adoption of standards for its web browsers (please don't complain about Flash, for starters it isn't a standard, for seconds its horrible, for thirds it is used mainly for adds which are also horrible, for fourths it violates usability and accessibility for fifths its one good use is dinky little free games, of which let me assure you I have it on good authority there are quite a few of those on the iOS). Apple is by no means perfect nor lily white, but to attack them on standards when they do so well in that area compared to most other companies is ... bizarre.

The only 'entertainment' companies that I can think of that do better at supporting a wide range of open formats are the small indie music and movie makers. Why doesn't Apple work with the indies to help them bring their content to a wider audience? That would be awesome. That you could legitimately complain about. But no, you pick something that Apple are actually good at to complain about. Why is it that when someone rants about Apple it is always opposites day???

The hilarious thing about your complaint is that all of the examples you give are obviously wrong, but there is a much better example: apps. Apps for iOS don't run on any other device.

...

The problem is, if you complained about that, you'd look silly, because as a general rule apps for one platform don't run on other platforms.

So anyway, to sum up the actual state of Apple 'lock-in':

(a) Open formats are supported on Apple products. (b) Some (e.g. music) closed formats are trivially easy to convert to open formats. (Turns out there are many converters for books that are cheap but not free, go figure) (c) iOS specific stuff is iOS specific (spot the tautology)

Would I prefer to be able to write apps for iOS in any language I wanted to? As a developer yes yes, OMG yes. As a consumer I would ask whether that means giving up the protections I currently enjoy.

What protections? Surely Apple's only purpose in life is to sell me sufficient numbers of these devices is to enslave my will to that of Skynet?

Not so! On my desktop I hardly download anything unless from a very highly trusted source. I especially distrust the free stuff. On the iOS devices I go wild and crazy, knowing that my private information is private, my data is safe.

So are you complaining about the walled garden? Why? There are a great many alternatives, none with gardens so nice. Leave the Apple lovers alone, the chains that bind them are so nice and shiny and make such pretty bracelets. Maybe if you're nice to them, one of them will bring you a drink of ice-water in your 'warm cosy place'.

Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by pavlov on Thursday February 17, 2011 @12:43PM (#2231869)
Sorry, but you're wrong. The iTunes DRM was ridiculously easy to circumvent even in iTunes itself. No mad leet hackzor skillz required. Since you could trivially turn aac files into mp3 files in iTunes [...]

Do you mean the "semi-analog hole" of burning protected tracks in iTunes to a CD-R, then ripping the disc back into MP3 tracks?

If so, I wouldn't call that trivial because it requires a physical medium and some level of knowledge about audio formats to realize the possibility (I think a layperson would not understand that AAC->CD->MP3 is no more lossy than AAC->MP3).

Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by chc on Thursday February 17, 2011 @02:38PM (#2232456)
I think the layperson would not know the word "lossy" to begin with, and would just know that doing X allows him to play his music.
Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by bad_user on Thursday February 17, 2011 @12:35PM (#2231840)

      I especially distrust the free stuff
I use free stuff all the time, it's just a "sudo aptitude install" away.

     On the iOS devices I go wild and crazy, knowing 
     that my private information is private, my data is safe
Tell that to Aaron Barr :) Or to the people that cooked up http://jailbreakme.com

Or to the dozens of apps in the App Store that use your unique device ID.

Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by Stormbringer on Thursday February 17, 2011 @03:16PM (#2232636)
Wasn't there an article on Slashdot not so long ago where some researcher had done a random sample of Android apps, and 50% of them were phoning home (sic) your private info?

--

The big Linux code repositories are an interesting case in point. I'll straight up give them the benefit of the doubt that there is no spyware or malware on them. But isn't there again this tension between the custodial and the wide open? I recall people complaining about the more tightly guarded ones being hard to get new stuff onto them, everything was out of date. Whereas on the more chaotic free for all ones you would often encounter problems with different apps requiring different versions of shared libraries.

Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by bad_user on Friday February 18, 2011 @12:23PM (#2236305)
Yes, that's why all data is not safe.

About Linux repositories: Debian's is tightly guarded indeed (although you can find the newest stuff in Sid, and usually install it without problems, even though you're using stable or testing, since only the dependencies need to be upgraded, not the whole OS to Sid).

The difference between Linux distros and Apple's App Store is that you can add third-party repositories whenever you want. And many of them are trustworthy anyway, since they are maintained by reputable community members.

Also, Debian packages are just zip archives. You can download and check out the contents of every available update. Can you do that with OS X or Windows?

So yes, walled gardens are fine, but let users choose to get out of them. Let users jailbreak their phones. Sure, void their warranty, put warnings in iTunes, but give them a device-specific way to do that instead of playing games of wack-a-mole.

The majority wouldn't go for the jailbreak anyway, since most people go with the defaults; but I'm kind of pissed that I have to wait ages before new kernel or other exploits are found and that are untethered, such that I can safely upgrade. Even with a jailbreak, I still buy stuff from iTunes and I'm still an iPhone user.

So why does Apple hate me so much? (not that the same thing can't be said about some Android phone makers, but we're talking about Apple).

Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by chwahoo on Thursday February 17, 2011 @01:26PM (#2232109)
I'm not sure that any of this disputes the original post's claim that Apple's bread and butter is vendor lock-in and there are legitimate reasons for users to oppose this.

It's not so much an indictment of Apple---pretty much everyone would like to find ways to keep their customers from jumping ship. In return, Apple has found a way to give their customers value in return for monopoly. By integrating all the parts--itunes (software and service), app store, ibooks, ipods, ipads, iphones, payments, etc---they can build things with a unified user experience that works.

Why I don't like this is that it makes it nearly impossible for Apple users to benefit from non-apple innovation in any of these areas. Would you like to try someone else's tablet or phone? Well I hope you didn't need any of that content from inside the apple ecosystem. Want to try someone elses book or magazine store on your idevice? Well Apple is now in the process of constructing barriers to this as well.

I don't accept your suggestion that people who don't like Apple's policies should "leave apple users alone" and choose an alternative. Problems like this can sometimes be mitigating by shedding light on them through discussion and complaint (i.e., the uproar about developing apps in alternative languages). At the very least, potential Apple customers need to be educated about the system they are buying into.

Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by enjo on Thursday February 17, 2011 @06:08PM (#2233320)
Could you tell me how to circumvent AAC copy protection? My wife has thousands of songs she can't easily transfer without ripping all of them, 15 or so at a time, to CD.
Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by Tyrannosaurs on Friday February 18, 2011 @05:07AM (#2234925)
Isn't this really just a case of a decision which became bad in hindsight as many technology purchasing decisions are?

In a market for music (and digital music) that was (and is) rife with choice, your wife (and others) chose the convenience of iTunes over portability of the format.

That is exactly the same sort of trade off as we all make in purchase we all make every day. In hindsight, particularly in a developing market, we may regret the decisions we make but that doesn't make the vendors acts anti-competitive or immoral or anything else any more than Betamax or Laser Disc or HD DVD was.

Besides, could be worse, she could have bought them on Mini Disc...

Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by mvalle on Thursday February 17, 2011 @07:00PM (#2233484)
Some Chinese people say, that the government only prevents them from seeing/reading bad stuff, and that censorship is, in general, a good thing.
Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by jongraehl on Thursday February 17, 2011 @01:43PM (#2232196)
AAC to mp3 conversion? If you like crap sound quality, sure.
Re:Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music s... by Stormbringer on Thursday February 17, 2011 @03:09PM (#2232601)
Damn those evil bastards at Apple for sending you the music in a high quality format.

/shakes fist at sky/

JJOOOOOOOOBBBBBSSSSSSSS!!!!!

(edit: for the kind souls burying me, see also: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wRnSnfiUI54