The old core of S.Fe contains almost none of the basic essential retail outlets for day to day life. There are no supermarkets, no hardware stores, for example (Kaunes is about as close it gets). You see very few people walking around other than tourists. It is true that the Rail Yards is a moderately successful (re)development of a downtown area that was previously ... well, rail yards. But it hasn't really done much to change the retail/hang out situation other than adding an REI, a brewery and a movie theater. All good things (for me) but they don't change the fact that living in S.Fe without a car will remind you constantly that you don't have a car.
One great thing here are hundreds of speed bumps on residential streets. These do provide a distinct message ("Slow the F*CK down") when driving in those neighorhoods, but they do not change the car-centric nature of the city.
Some people might even consider the Trader Joes on Cordova to be within the boundaries of "the core" (along with the Natural Grocer catty-corner opposite), but I think that's pushing it a bit.
It's very walkable if you're visiting or enjoying a day in town. It's very unwalkable if you need to get normal day to day or week to week shopping done.
The transit/'burbs thing is probably true, but I live so far from the city that I'm not really familiar with the transit situation.