You can have largely pedestrianized areas in the interior with these sorts of things but, in general, you need to provide parking because a lot of people are going to need/want to use a car to get to them even if they're on some sort of transit route.
They also tend to work better in moderate climates. One example of something along these lines in the Bay Area is Santana Row. Very clearly artificial but still relatively pleasant.
Another setup I see in the exurbs are planned communities. You basically take everything a neighborhood needs and build a wall around it. My sister lives in one on a lake, it's pretty neat, everyone drives golf-carts around instead of cars which is funny/interesting. Also, they have their own holiday festivals and events so the community is pretty close knit. My sister's kids know all the other neighborhood kids and all the parents know each other. The parents keep an eye out and so the kids are given a lot of freedom to roam and do kid stuff they wouldn't normally be able to do in the standard suburban neighborhood with heavy and fast traffic everywhere.