News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Cognitive Style of Unix by long on Thursday February 17, 2011 @01:55AM (#2230122)
In fact they did. They measured total task time for internalized versus externalized conditions. Contra your prediction, there wasn't a significant difference. Keep in mind this is one limited experiment so it's obviously not the final say, but it's always good to actually look at the data.
Re:The Cognitive Style of Unix by j_random_hacker on Thursday February 17, 2011 @05:23AM (#2230473)
Thanks, you're quite right. Having now skimmed the paper "Does an interface with less assistance provoke more thoughtful behavior?", I would say that the measures of how many moves were made or remade, and how long was taken before the first move, are basically irrelevant, as the only quantities of genuine interest are how long the solution takes, and how well the subjects did on the questions afterwards. As you say, there was no significant difference in average solution time -- even though the low-NFC group did on average 19s better on the externalised version. Nor was there a statistically significant difference in either of the question types (although one type was close to favouring the internalised approach at p = 0.06). Maybe the other papers are more persuasive.
Re:The Cognitive Style of Unix by JoachimSchipper on Thursday February 17, 2011 @05:59AM (#2230530)
Just to clarify: are we talking about "learning the interface" plus "accomplishing task" here, or just "accomplishing task"? I'm pretty sure that e.g. unzipping your first archive with WinZip can be done more quickly than untarring your first archive with tar...
Re:The Cognitive Style of Unix by long on Thursday February 17, 2011 @11:51AM (#2231612)
Both people had to learn to use an interface for scheduling speakers on a calendar GUI. Roughly speaking, in the externalized condition, more problem constraints were identifiable through visual feedback, while these were absent and had to be inferred in the internalized condition.

So, (in this paper), we're talking about planning versus relying on more external visual cues. Your WinZip versus tar example is apt, but it also introduces the issue of GUI versus CLI, which isn't addressed by the paper.