News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A popular self-driving car dataset is missing labels for ... by ummonk on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:28PM (#22301063)
Given that nuclear power is significantly safer than other forms of power, are you asserting that the risks of self-driving cars are more about PR and perception than actual risk?
Re:A popular self-driving car dataset is missing labels for ... by mumblemumble on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:37PM (#22301189)
I'm saying that nuclear power could have been a safer energy option, but, in practice, the whole enterprise has been scuttled by a bunch of regrettably bad decisions that have pretty much destroyed everyone's trust. So now it doesn't really matter if it's safer, because it can no longer realistically be considered an option.
Re:A popular self-driving car dataset is missing labels for ... by keenmaster on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:40PM (#22302582)
If everyone believes that everyone else will be irrational, then they themselves will not throw their support behind nuclear power, rendering their stance on nuclear de facto irrational. As Baby Boomers age, and Millennials/GenZ form a greater percentage of the voting population, we have an opportunity to press the reset button on nuclear. The younger generations don’t really have a solid opinion on the matter, and probably don’t think about it much.

Scientists are in the best position to influence the public and push for change. It is astonishing that scientific organizations have been timid about nuclear energy, or outright against it, because of a few people with the most extreme, empirically unjustified stance.

Re:A popular self-driving car dataset is missing labels for ... by kozd on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:36PM (#22303149)
Is it a tautology or just an unfortunate nash equilibrium?
Re:A popular self-driving car dataset is missing labels for ... by keenmaster on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:42PM (#22312590)
As you know, a nash equilibrium is the point at which no player can benefit from a move away from the equilibrium. However, that's a concept from game theory. What is the game here? Who are the players?

Part of my point is that you might think that the game is "scientists vs. politicians, ignoramuses, and fear-mongers," but that's not the case. Sometimes they're all on the same side. Imagine a 4 player split-screen Star Fox, where the scientist leaves their controller and helps the others shoot down their plane because they don't think they can win. If that sounds baffling, it is.

Re:A popular self-driving car dataset is missing labels for ... by MrQuincle on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @01:42AM (#22306465)
Check this concept car from 1957: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Nucleon

We could have had your safe nuclear power involved in every road accident. Yeah!

Re:A popular self-driving car dataset is missing labels for ... by jwandborg on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:45PM (#22301275)
I think the point is rather that it's an unpredictable-stakes game. That is, if you make few enough mistakes, you'll be fine for a long time until you make the wrong mistake at the wrong time and it kills somebody.

Maybe a better analogy is driving a car, that is, nuclear power and self-driving cars are both vaguely like driving a car.

However, my intuition is that nuclear power has less variables than driving a car. I say intuition because I don't know much about neither.

I think the point is that self-driving cars trained on poor data are no better than poorly trained superhumans at driving.

Re:A popular self-driving car dataset is missing labels for ... by perl4ever on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @08:12PM (#22304770)
"However, my intuition is that nuclear power has less variables than driving a car."

During the cold war they launched fission reactors into orbit. That probably had more variables. Then again, since the nuclear airplane project was unsuccessful, maybe that had the most variables of all.

Re:A popular self-driving car dataset is missing labels for ... by jwandborg on Thursday February 13, 2020 @02:58PM (#22320907)
Well, nuclear power isn't harder because you put it in a car, but it's a great way to add to the complexity of the system as a whole.

Putting a nuclear reactor in space (as we still do, I think the most recent Mars rover had one) greatly reduces the risk of it directly causing deaths, since it's really far away from humans for most of its service life.