News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by jgrahamc on Friday June 20, 2008 @12:53PM (#222895)
Wow! A summary of privacy settings. Amazing! It's so original and clever. Boy, I wish other software could have a summary of privacy settings. We could even generalize this to summaries of other sorts of settings.

My head spins with the genius of it. I think I need a lie down.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by mynameishere on Friday June 20, 2008 @05:35PM (#223239)
Oh, yeah. Sarcasm detector. That's a real useful invention.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by osipov on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:16PM (#222922)
I'm not a shilling for Zuckerberg but you are being too hard on him. First, the patent isn't for "summary of privacy settings", it is for a systems/methods to generate the said summary. Second, a patent isn't supposed to be original or clever. The criteria are 1) novel, which can be a non-original, i.e. a derivative work. 2) non-obvious (to one skilled in the arts) or in other words non-obvious to a patent examiner who doesn't know much except for some prior patents in the field.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by axod on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:32PM (#222943)
Any software patent is 'non-obvious' to a non-programmer. That's the problem with them.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by plusbryan on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:34PM (#222946)
them = patents, or non-programmers?
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by mcxx on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:56PM (#222987)
Patents, of course.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by tlrobinson on Friday June 20, 2008 @02:34PM (#223030)
Well the real problem is the patent examiners probably aren't programmers, thus won't have a good idea of what should be patentable.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by kobs on Friday June 20, 2008 @03:29PM (#223108)
For most CS students/programmers, I'd wager that being a patent examiner isn't very alluring. This is even more evident at career fairs where representatives from the USPTO have to get in your face to grab your attention. You just don't see too many students lining up to talk to them, rather than say, Google or Microsoft.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by Hexstream on Friday June 20, 2008 @05:54PM (#223258)
I can't decide if he was joking or not.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by osipov on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:55PM (#222983)
I think your statement lacks nuance and insight I came to expect from ycnews.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by axod on Friday June 20, 2008 @03:24PM (#223103)
So why not give your opinion, and add to the debate? Do you think most software patents are non-obvious? How can a software patent be non-obvious? All programs are pretty obvious. Algorithms, not so much, but then you're talking more mathematics, which should not be patentable anyway.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by osipov on Friday June 20, 2008 @04:27PM (#223184)
>"All programs are pretty obvious. Algorithms, not so much."

How do you expect anyone to respond to something like that? Are you suggesting programs are not algorithms? Can you point to an authoritative reference explaining the difference?

I gave my informed opinion on patents, unfortunately this site is turning into reddit just like reddit turned into digg.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by axod on Friday June 20, 2008 @05:02PM (#223217)
There's a big difference between "System and apparatus to display 'hello world'", and say an encryption algorithm.

Yes it's a blurred line, but I'd say most programs are todo lists, rather than complex algorithms of scientific merit.

For example, say the software that runs facebook - that's pretty much going to be 'grunt work' - lots of building blocks, shoved together, to make something work.

But a compression algorithm, has more of a basis in mathematics entropy etc.

My sincere apologies if this once again disappoints your view of what comments on hacker news should be.

(I have several software patents, but I firmly believe they are a terrible idea).

Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by ComputerGuru on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:38PM (#222954)
Sorry, but Windows has had the ability to generate summaries of privacy settings ever since NT and the creation of NTFS w/ ACL configuration. It's called "Effective Permissions" and tells you - bottom line, all settings and configurations taken into account - what each user can access and what they can't.

Obviously MS hasn't contested this patent yet, but I wonder what they'll do when they read it up....

Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by osipov on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:53PM (#222977)
Again, the patent isn't for "ability to generate summaries of privacy settings". The patent is for systems/methods to do so. Consider a patent for systems/methods of flying. Such a patent doesn't infringe on attempts of flying, just on systems/methods described by the patent.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by brfox on Friday June 20, 2008 @05:42PM (#223245)
Note to readers: this is a patent application, not an issued patent.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by nadim on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:12PM (#222917)
Sounds like a good candidate for the EFF patent busting project: http://w2.eff.org/patent/

Anyone know of any prior art?

(I don't know if they pick patents to bust on their own or take requests)

EDIT: If the above poster osipov is correct and this patent is legit/novel, please disregard my comment.

[deleted]
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by jrockway on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:31PM (#222941)
Why? Software patents suck regardless of whether or not they are novel. Each one slowly kills our profession.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by ComputerGuru on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:39PM (#222955)
It isn't novel. See my reply above.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by kirubakaran on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:15PM (#222921)
I request everyone to donate to EFF.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by jzawodny on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:19PM (#222925)
amen
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by tstegart on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:44PM (#222963)
This is a joke right? I mean, it sounds like the patent for a web form. Get info, use info, deliver it back to user. Replace privacy summary with almost anything else and you have a basic function of most websites.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by okeumeni on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:58PM (#222991)
Lets all say it the way it should be: this is a joke!! A patent for a high school level process programming? Come on!

Sorry I had to post another comment after actually reading the whole stuff.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by okeumeni on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:14PM (#222918)
If this patent weren’t from the founder of Facebook it will almost sound funny. I have never seen anything like this.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by t0pj on Friday June 20, 2008 @02:15PM (#223004)
IMHO, MZ as inventor of said patent makes this funny*scary^2.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by fourlittlebees on Friday June 20, 2008 @06:44PM (#223295)
Look at the patent app again. It's not just privacy settings; it's the blueprint for the mechanism that the Data Portability group has been talking about. That's why Zuckerberg doesn't want Facebook to really play their reindeer games. They want to build it themselves and have Facebook as the hub of the wheel with spokes off to everything else.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by pixcavator on Friday June 20, 2008 @02:29PM (#223023)
After reading the discussion I have to point out the obvious: it's an application not a patent.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by jonknee on Friday June 20, 2008 @02:30PM (#223025)
I thought it was going to be about a system of being a dick to everyone you've ever done business with or who helped you early on, but this is almost as obvious.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by okeumeni on Friday June 20, 2008 @02:35PM (#223031)
Say it loud! more details please.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by jmzachary on Saturday June 21, 2008 @12:12AM (#223474)
I wonder if they submitted this patent application in crayon. The abstract reads like it was written by a third grader.
[deleted]
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by tlrobinson on Friday June 20, 2008 @02:46PM (#223051)
I'll go ahead and disclose this for you:

YOU are the one filing this petition for cancellation of the "Facebook" trademark.

After a brief look at your company's press releases and submissions to Hacker News it appears you're on a mission to either profit from Facebook's success, or destroy them.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/01/technology/01facebook.html...

Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by tlrobinson on Friday June 20, 2008 @03:00PM (#223075)
The parent post which was deleted linked to this petition for the cancelation of the "Facebook" trademark:

http://ttabvue.uspto.gov/ttabvue/v?pno=92049206&pty=CAN

Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by thinkcomp on Friday June 20, 2008 @02:57PM (#223069)
I'm not sure I understand your apparent outrage. What exactly do I stand to gain from posting a link to USPTO TTAB proceedings on Hacker News? In my opinion, trademarking a generic term is just as ridiculous as patenting an obvious process. Either way, I deleted the post containing the link you found offensive.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Patent by tlrobinson on Friday June 20, 2008 @05:12PM (#223225)
It seemed like a conflict of interest of sorts for you to be pointing out Facebook's trademark troubles, when you were the one causing them, without disclosing that.

Sorry if I was (and still am...) a bit harsh, but from where I stand it seems like you're another bitter Facebook competitor. You and ConnectU and Zuckerberg may have had similar ideas around the same time, but Zuckerberg executed it successfully, and I don't think that means you're entitled to anything.

As far as generic trademarks go, what about trademarks like "Apple"? It's also worth noting I had never really heard the term "face book" before thefacebook.com; it seems like it was mostly a Harvard thing)