Re:A half century ago, better transistors revolutionized com...
by nwallin on Sunday February 09, 2020 @09:16PM
(#22285860)
Define "good enough oscilloscope"? A rigol 1054z can be had for $4-500. What do you need from an oscilloscope that the 1054z doesn't provide?
I'm not saying you're wrong, I just don't understand.
Re:A half century ago, better transistors revolutionized com...
by analog31 on Sunday February 09, 2020 @09:27PM
(#22285915)
That's probably good enough, but certainly better than what I have at home. In fact, I bought a couple of those for my workplace.
Re:A half century ago, better transistors revolutionized com...
by rasz on Sunday February 09, 2020 @10:06PM
(#22286117)
How is owning an oscilloscope capable of <~50KHz BW an issue? Those are the only frequencies you should be worried about in an audio amp.
Re:A half century ago, better transistors revolutionized com...
by detaro on Sunday February 09, 2020 @10:11PM
(#22286147)
Not for testing a class-D amp, which switches in the MHz range, and you do want to test if it's stable, if your filters actually get rid of the HF parts, ... And even for an analog design 50kHz wouldn't really be enough for many potential problems which happen above that. Worrying just about the audio range is not enough.
Even the commercial amplifier makers have mostly reverted to buy-in modules. Most of the "mini amps" sold for bass guitar contain IcePower modules made by a division of Bang & Olufsen.
I've gone so far as to simulate a switchmode amplifier in LTSpice just for fun. I'm quite heavily into electronics, but have made it a personal rule not to mess around with homemade line powered equipment that I would actually take to a performance. I don't want to become known as the whiz kid whose homemade gear blew up on stage. ;-)
At lower power levels, there are some IC's made by Texas Instruments and others that shouldn't be too difficult to apply, but you can also get entire amplifier boards with these chips from online suppliers for next to nothing.