Re:Ask HN: Does anyone else realize that Quora is just a fan...
by neworbit on Thursday February 17, 2011 @02:17PM
(#2232363)
That's a good summary, if perhaps a little down on the HN knowledge base than I'd suspect.
For instance, I'm afraid I can tell you an awful lot about tinnitus but I would be happier if I hadn't had the occasion to learn about it.
The mods on HN would kill a question like the following one, no doubt: http://www.quora.com/It-is-possible-to-drop-a-marshmallow-fr...
The discussion on the Tiger Mom stuff was much better on Quora than HN: http://www.quora.com/Parenting/Is-Amy-Chua-right-when-she-ex...
Hacker News is great at answering startup and coding-related questions, but none of you will be able to answer this one: http://www.quora.com/Hearing/Why-and-how-do-we-hear-ringing-...
Quora has an incredible array of people with domain expertise, many of whom are good writers who tend towards writing much longer answers than what you see on HN. I can't exactly pinpoint why the design of Quora prompts such a different array of questions and answers, beyond the different user base, but it's definitely not a fancy HN. It's trying to solve a different problem. If anything, it's a fancy cross between the Q&A-ness of Yahoo! Answers and a rabid, tight-knit fangirl community, but it's much better executed than Yahoo! Answers so far.