News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First viable compressed air car: get 200-300km per tank o... by tx on Friday June 20, 2008 @09:42AM (#222731)
Ok, we won't be burning gasoline in a vehicle, we'll be burning it to compress air when refueling.

For similar reasons I don't get the fuss about electric "zero-emission" cars. Zero? Like electricity just magically comes out of nowhere...

Re:First viable compressed air car: get 200-300km per tank o... by asp742 on Friday June 20, 2008 @10:20AM (#222748)
It's like software. If you cleanly separate the front-end and back-end it's very easy to tune and swap out the back-end without the user noticing.
Re:First viable compressed air car: get 200-300km per tank o... by tx on Friday June 20, 2008 @12:43PM (#222886)
Like your analogy! :) The bigger picture is that we're approaching an energy crisis. That's why gas is getting more expensive, and that is why there is even an interest in these cars to begin with: the message isn't to "separate front end and back end" but to appeal to people who want to save money on energy costs, i.e. gasoline. But it won't work, because gasoline is just the medium, the real beef here is energy, and it's not going to get cheaper because we need more and more of it. It's not only gasoline that's getting expensive, my gas and electric bills are ahead of inflation as well.

"Solutions" covered by the press aren't really solving the problem, they're just shifting it around. "Wow! We have an air-powered car!" - without an explanation where the energy to compress that air is going to come from...

Re:First viable compressed air car: get 200-300km per tank o... by jcl on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:24PM (#222931)
If you assume the problem is "Where will we find energy to sustain our current consumption rate?", then you're right: air-cars aren't a solution. Such a solution might not even exist.

But if you assume the problem is "How can we relieve market pressure on our most constrained resource?", air and electric cars are a solution. The hope is that by diversifying the sources of energy used for transportation, we can continue to use oil for other purposes that we haven't found cost-effective replacements for yet -- like plastics and jet fuel.

So while the cars won't solve the energy crisis by themselves, maybe they'll buy us enough time to reach the "then a miracle occurs" discovery that does solve it. Or, failing that, maybe they'll help civilization make a slow transition to reduced consumption, rather than a sharp crash.

Re:First viable compressed air car: get 200-300km per tank o... by khafra on Friday June 20, 2008 @02:36PM (#223033)
Materials science needs to get on the ball and invent Adamantium, from Marvel Comics. Then we can have compressed air-powered airliners.
Re:First viable compressed air car: get 200-300km per tank o... by jcl on Friday June 20, 2008 @10:11AM (#222744)
Most likely we wouldn't be burning gasoline to compress air for these cars: gas is expensive. Instead, we'd probably use electricity derived from coal, natural gas, or nuclear, with the possibility of better sources in the future.

"Zero-emission" is a reasonable description, as the car itself doesn't give off emissions while running. If you're going to include the emissions given off in the process of producing the fuel, a gasoline-based solution is suddenly much worse, as you need to include the emission costs of finding, extracting, refining, and transporting the gas.

Re:First viable compressed air car: get 200-300km per tank o... by run4yourlives on Friday June 20, 2008 @01:54PM (#222981)
Not all of us burn stuff to make electricity. In BC, all our power is hydro.
Re:First viable compressed air car: get 200-300km per tank o... by rw on Friday June 20, 2008 @03:13PM (#223094)
What we don't need are more dams in our waterways.
Re:First viable compressed air car: get 200-300km per tank o... by run4yourlives on Friday June 20, 2008 @03:17PM (#223098)
Well, you can always live with the lights off then. Given what's currently possible, dams are the best solution to this problem out there.