News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft: No GPLv3 Software for Windows Phone and Xbox A... by halostatue on Wednesday February 16, 2011 @11:34AM (#2227032)
Share-Alike licenses like the GNU GPL are excellent licenses and are worthy of consideration for whole categories of software.

What they aren't, however, is 'free' by any rational or sane definition of the word. They impose restrictions -- and carry those restrictions downstream -- on the use of the software that increases the theoretical range of people who would do things with the software. But those restrictions in and of themselves do not increase "freedom" for anyone.

Like I said, there's good reasons to choose these sorts of licenses. What I object to are the semantic games and occasionally outright lies and histrionics of GNU GPL supporters.

Re:Microsoft: No GPLv3 Software for Windows Phone and Xbox A... by ajross on Wednesday February 16, 2011 @01:09PM (#2227475)
So maybe it would be nice if they wrote up an essay somewhere detailing exactly what they mean by "freedom" so that no one gets confused. Maybe they could call it the "The Free Software Definition".

http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html

I'll leave aside the issue of whether or not this matches what you consider a "rational" or "sane" definition of "free" and just point out that it makes pretty good sense to me.