"If it seems like we are over-eager to defend ourselves because we know that we are somehow in the wrong, it is because we are, at least partially. Working on this translation has meant going against Grothendieck’s explicit requests, and for that we are sorry. We only hope that the freedom of knowledge is an excusable defense."
Tell this to the politicians who created the copyright laws.
I am sure Grothendieck would be on the front lines of those castigating such politicians. He made this request not to ensure personal gain, but to express his profound disappointment with and disengagement from society as he saw it.
Unless I misread that and he only intended to restrict copies "without my consent". Hence as broad and varied distribution as he solely wished, and no others.
I think I read that initially as a fear of being misunderstood, since every new copy would have a non-zero chance of typos or changes. Or I have that entirely wrong, which is the more likely case.
Curious.
https://tqft.net/misc/Grothendieck's%20Declaration.pdf
``` Declaration of intent of non-publication
I do not intend to publish or republish any work or text of which I am the author, in any form whatsoever, printed or electronic, whether in full or in excerpts, texts of personal nature, of scientific character, or otherwise, or letters addressed to anybody, and any translation of texts of which I am the author. Any edition or dissemination of such texts which have been made in the past without my consent, or which will be made in the future and as long as I live, is against my will expressly specified here and is unlawful in my eyes. As I learn of these, I will ask the person responsible for such pirated editions, or of any other publication containing without permission texts from my hand (beyond possible citations of a few lines each), to remove from commerce these books; and librarians holding such books to remove these books from those libraries.
If my intentions, clearly expressed here, should go unheeded, then the shame of it falls on those responsible for the illegal editions, and those responsible for the libraries concerned (as soon as they have been informed of my intention).
Written at my home, January 3, 2010,
Alexandre Grothendieck. ```