News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if ... by bogdanoff_2 on Thursday February 06, 2020 @01:02AM (#22253762)
The takeaway from the first story is simple: don't be a jerk.

It's harder to find a takeaway from the second story. How do you in general avoid making whatever mistakes Bill supposedly made with his seminar?

Re:The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if ... by Traster on Thursday February 06, 2020 @04:48AM (#22254787)
He was a new person being asked to do something new to him that literally everyone else around him had previously done. It's not rocket science, ask the opinion of the more experienced people around you. The message from the first story is identical to the message from the first - recognise the value of other people's work.
Re:The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if ... by Archit3ch on Thursday February 06, 2020 @10:43AM (#22256823)
> It's not rocket science, ask the opinion of the more experienced people around you.

You assume that being humble and acting in good faith will get you ahead in academic politics. From firsthand (but not personal) experience, sometimes you can do everything right and people will still get offended. You'll find no evidence of what went wrong, trying to piece together the event sequence after the fact, much like OP's experience. Of course, OP went out of their way to offend, I don't recommend that.

Academics tend to minimize risk [1]. If you try to interpret their behavior outside of that context, you will find it inscrutable, because not only are they playing in a different league, they aren't even playing the same game [1].

[1] much like C suites

Re:The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if ... by sandoooo on Thursday February 06, 2020 @01:16AM (#22253820)
Knowing the culture and relative status dynamics would have helped. Undergrads are lower than the worms beneath your feet as faculty, and shouldn't be invited to faculty gatherings lest they drool on the carpet.

By not figuring out what the faux pas's are for the local ecosystem, he was setting himself up for failure. If it wasn't this talk it would have been something else.

Re:The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if ... by smallcharleston on Thursday February 06, 2020 @01:54AM (#22254007)
Are they? As an undergrad I thought my professors were silly folks who got suckered into making a huge effort on obscure facts when they could easily make the same salary with less energy in software/IT. When a prof I did research with behaved rudely to me I just quit his lab and got someone else to write grad school letters for me. Academically all but the best undergrads know basically nothing, but looking down on them seems like you’ll soon have lab a labor shortage to me, especially in CS.
Re:The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if ... by Fronzie on Thursday February 06, 2020 @02:30AM (#22254197)
undergrads don't bring in grant money, but do cost time (teaching). From a university 'business' point of view, they are a net loss.

Grants are a big thing in academia.

Re:The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if ... by limbicsystem on Thursday February 06, 2020 @04:32AM (#22254733)
In the UK it's exactly the opposite. Here's the best case (UCL - a super research intensive university): https://www.ucl.ac.uk/students/fees-and-funding/how-ucl-uses... Most other universities rely far more on teaching. Tuition fees also have the advantage that they are constant and relatively easy to predict while grants last a few years at best (and of course you do have to >do< something with them so they are not pure profit. Broadly, grants are the delicious froth on top of the tuition fee latte.
Re:The secret of academic success, or fun filled failure if ... by smallcharleston on Thursday February 06, 2020 @10:16PM (#22262937)
It’s not always true. I know an undergrad who had a conference paper out in a direction a PI could use in grant writing.