News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The mysteries of aerodynamic lift by Retric on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @02:22PM (#22239821)
The billiard ball model works fine when you include the impact of other billboard balls on each other resulting in vortexes etc. It’s simply computationally expensive to do so.

Anyway, absolutely flat wings generate lift as long as the angle of attack is non zero. But, by changing the wings shape they get more efficient. The reasons for that are complex differential equations that don’t really have simple plain English explanations, which is why people do so much testing and simulation. Aka simple 2d diagrams don’t result in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wingtip_device

What’s even more confusing is most wing diagrams put the center line in the wrong location. If you take a symmetrical tear drop shape with zero angle of attack the bottom will be sloped up at the same angle the top slopes down. Thus if you instead lay that teardrop so the bottom is flat that represents a positive angle of attack. Granted, wings generally don’t have a symmetric shape, but similar principles apply.

Re:The mysteries of aerodynamic lift by usrusr on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @05:30PM (#22241782)
A nice first approximation extension of the billiard ball model is to look at a stalled wing in comparison to an un-stalled: the down side will continue to "deflect the balls" just fine. But while the un-stalled upper side of a wing will also draw air downwards in an orderly way, the stalled upper side pulls a tail of vortices forwards. Not strictly a billiard ball model anymore, but even the crudest model of turbulent flow is enough to get the general idea.

The purpose of an airfoil, in this approximation, is giving the pulled air a longer, gentler acceleration compared to the short peak of acceleration a flat wing would require at the same angle of attack. You won't be able to calculate optimal airfoils with this model, or even a winglet, but it's good enough for many of the usual little riddles like symmetric airfoils, inverted flying etc.

Re:The mysteries of aerodynamic lift by dhxjncdggxghbh on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @10:57PM (#22243879)
Symmetric airfoils (which do exist) are considered to have a centerline in the obvious (symmetric) place, but this doesn't have anything to do with angle of attack. For various reasons, aerobatic planes sometimes have symmetric airfoils with an angle of incidence of zero—that is, the aircraft centerline and airfoil centerline are parallel.

https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/7560/what-are-t...

Angle of attack is a separate issue.

Re:The mysteries of aerodynamic lift by Retric on Wednesday February 05, 2020 @09:17AM (#22246825)
I am saying the choice of centerline for an airfoil is arbitrary in terms of aerodynamic forces. The angle of incidence is then based on that arbitrary centerline. The aircraft’s angle of attack is independent of the above and therefore confusing.

To be clear I am not saying how the wing is mounted arbitrary, just what angle is written down in the documentation. Chose a different centerline and that angle changes even as the aircraft stays the same.

Re:The mysteries of aerodynamic lift by keanzu on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:07PM (#22240335)
> Aka simple 2d diagrams don’t result in wingtip devices

Why not? You have a flat plate with high pressure below and low pressure above. Air escapes around the end of the plate at the wingtip from the high pressure to the low pressure area, reducing net force. So you put some sort of barrier to impede the flow - a wingtip device.

Re:The mysteries of aerodynamic lift by starpilot on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:15PM (#22240427)
2d wing does not have a wing "tip." It is infinite.
Re:The mysteries of aerodynamic lift by numpad0 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @09:23PM (#22243431)
> Thus if you instead lay that teardrop so the bottom is flat

The thing is, both sides of a wing are defined by some nonlinear polynomials, and aft edges are sharp. Machinists don’t/can’t use such surfaces for any reference purposes so centerline can’t be there.