News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:List of content farms to block with Google Personal Block... by chc on Tuesday February 15, 2011 @02:46PM (#2222888)
Point 2 only applies if you blindly apply any blacklist you come across. If people who blindly obey everything they're told are so numerous, this "arms race" should exist just as much with word-of-mouth and blacklists aren't introducing a new problem.
Re:List of content farms to block with Google Personal Block... by elsewhen on Tuesday February 15, 2011 @03:06PM (#2223019)
i am sure that hacker-news users are savvy enough to check each site one-by-one, but blacklist-sharing in general can be detrimental if they get distributed to mainstream users.

imagine if these lists get to be 100-domains long... some users are simply going to take the shortcut and apply-all. the due-diligence required to cull a good list takes time. the very fact that this post is getting upvoted is because even hacker-news users are looking for shortcuts.

blacklists introduce a new problem: SEOs distributing such lists that include lots of weak sites (to make the list look credible) along with their competitor's domain snuck in.

Re:List of content farms to block with Google Personal Block... by chc on Tuesday February 15, 2011 @03:19PM (#2223082)
So, again, it's a matter of trusting your source. Just like with word of mouth.
Re:List of content farms to block with Google Personal Block... by elsewhen on Tuesday February 15, 2011 @04:25PM (#2223392)
word of mouth is typically a one-by-one recommendation, where doing your own research is straightforward and quick. ie, if a friend recommends a movie for you to watch, you might check it out, read the reviews, and then add it to your netflix queue.

with a long list, doing the due diligence becomes orders-of-magnitude more labor intensive, so users are more incented to just copy/paste an entire list. in the case of netflix queues, perhaps there isn't too much at stake... but with a domain blacklist, SEOs and spammers have their entire livelihoods at stake... if this extension takes off, and if google starts using this data, i would expect well-funded SEOs to start heavily promoting their lists (with their sites omitted, and their competitor's sites included).

of course hacker-news users may be immune from such tricks, but we represent just a minority of the data that google will get from this tool... if it goes mainstream, i am sad to admit that my parents are likely fall for "follow these simple steps to dramatically improve your google results"