News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by duxup on Monday February 03, 2020 @01:39PM (#22227380)
>convenient coincidences favoring whoever has the ability to cause them.

I feel like that by default would just mean everything involving anyone with any power (or even little) would be thought to be a conspiracy.

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by simion314 on Monday February 03, 2020 @01:59PM (#22227617)
The thing that makes me believe that the evidence was planted is because is such an easy thing to do and it does a lot more damage, if there were some financial transcation then there would be some more evidence to corroborate it, if it was some objects or property again there would be a lot more things to corroborate, with porn you just plant a file or a stick and then the you show the jury some disturbing image and you are done, you destroyed the person, lazy and efficient.

The article does not mention it and I would like to know if it is know if this was some files on his laptop, or was in his browser cache or browser history or an USB stick

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by shadowgovt on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:06PM (#22228391)
Ironically, it's the sort of tampering that more "privacy violation" by third-parties could help protect people against. Storing your behavior in the clutches of multiple competing firms with multiple conflicting interests can make it easier to protect one against an attack on reputation that involves modifying one data store.

"Your honor, the prosecution claims my client had CP on his hard drive, yet it does not appear in either his Apple backups nor his Google Drive synchronization images..."

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by simion314 on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:02PM (#22229048)
It does not have to be like that, you should be able to find traces in recent played videos opened files, what is ironic is that you have a high visibility person like Epstein that FBI is incompetent to catch for years but for some reasons the people they have reasons to find something the evidence just appears... it just feels this laws are not used to protect children/teens but to punish the ones the government doesn't like.
Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by shadowgovt on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:19PM (#22229230)
Possible alternate explanation: Epstein had the resources to pay people to obfuscate the trail of any investigators trying to dig up dirt on him, and $J_RANDOM_CIA_STAFFER does not.
Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by zionic on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:36PM (#22228057)
>I would like to know if it is know if this was some files on his laptop, or was in his browser cache or browser history or an USB stick

That kind of stuff will never be released though.

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by livueta on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:26PM (#22230001)
Given the national security aspect of this case you might be right, but in general a lot of dirty details about the hows and wheres of CP cases comes out eventually in court filings.

Exhibit A: "Mad Thad" McMichael / https://imgur.com/a/xr2IH - of "\things\dont click\cp\cp" fame.

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by ghostbrainalpha on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:16PM (#22227826)
You don't think it defies logic that a SOFTWARE ENGINEER who works for the CIA, would leave such an obvious trail to a horrific crime on his home computer?

This person has intelligence, technical acumen, and is immersed in secrecy and privacy at an extreme level on a daily basis.

Maybe people are just dumber than we want to credit them for. But I don't think its "conspiracy theory" to find this indecent strange.

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by shadowgovt on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:09PM (#22228414)
> You don't think it defies logic that a SOFTWARE ENGINEER who works for the CIA, would leave such an obvious trail to a horrific crime on his home computer?

The history of people being arrested for crime suggests no. People who are incredibly savvy in one field have been incredibly stupid in what should have been a very-closely-related field.

Entirely too many politicians who know how much people talk have had their careers tarnished by unpopular sexual trysts, for example.

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by ghostbrainalpha on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:13PM (#22228454)
That's all true. Maybe it is just people are that stupid.

Here is ANOTHER article from Today about a famous Hacker being arrested for child porn.

https://kotaku.com/nintendo-switch-hacker-busted-also-pleads...

It just feels like from reading the news, that to be an illegal hacker it's almost a requirement to have tons of child porn on your personal computers.

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by dontbenebby on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:43PM (#22228806)
You're assuming CIA software engineers are good at their jobs, and that engineers have opsec skills

Those are two big assumptions.

HN is usually pretty logical, so I find it odd that people are jumping to conclusions here.

Jumping from "the CIA is all elite software engineers" to "CIA engineers must have extraordinary opsec" to "if unencrypted evidence was found, the most likely explanation is it was planted" requires several wild leaps.

Maybe the same sort of person who blows up their life by leaking classified information and does it in a manner sloppy enough to at least be accused of the crime is also careless to not properly cover up other crimes?

Also, clandestine service and analyst roles are two very different roles housed under the same agency. Not everyone in the CIA is in clandestine service. (In fact it's my understanding the vast majority are not)

I have no idea if this person is guilty, that's what a trial is for. But I'm not going to say the presence of evidence is evidence of innocence - that seems like extremely flimsy, circular logic.

Then again, I've never held a clearance or worked a government job - this is all just my own analysis based on open source information, so take what I say with a grain of salt :)

Folks may want to read this article:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/adamcurtis/entries/3662a707-0af9...

(There's also a HN discussion thread for that article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14500633)

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by rbanffy on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:11PM (#22228429)
This person went through one of the most demanding interviewing process on the planet and has passed probably more than one interrogation without anyone suspecting he was a paedophile.

I'm really not sure which possible assertions is more disturbing: that the FBI would frame him or that the CIA may be full of paedophiles.

Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak by rbanffy on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:07PM (#22228403)
> I feel like that by default would just mean everything involving anyone with any power

Precisely. We give them the power to search our houses and take away our freedom because we trust them to do The Right Thing. When this trust is broken, we are in a very bad place.