Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak
by zionic on Monday February 03, 2020 @01:36PM
(#22227354)
While that's a great point and a likely defense, the play is more often than not to charge you with lying (and scare you with the max jail time threat) to then coerce you to be an informant or work with them in some other way.
We essentially have state-sanctioned black mail.
Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak
by ldiracdelta on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @12:17PM
(#22238168)
The process is the punishment.
Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak
by Tomte on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:29PM
(#22227976)
From https://www.popehat.com/2011/03/18/just-a-friendly-reminder-...
> here was no chance whatsoever that your denial — whether it was a panic-induced brain fart, or a failure of memory, or a lie — could have misled or deterred the FBI in its investigation for even a moment. But that doesn't matter. Though materiality is an element of Section 1001, it's a weak, diluted type of materiality. Statements to the government are deemed material if they are the sort of statements that have the capacity to influence it. Courts have come very close to creating a presumption of materiality by reasoning that if the information were not material the government would not have asked for it and you wouldn't have offered it.
Re:Ex-CIA Software Engineer Goes on Trial for Vault 7 Leak
by ALittleLight on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:24PM
(#22227920)
If I'm allowed to write your testimony, I can be sure you'll make a material lie though.
While I completely agree that "lying to a federal agent" is a charge that is open to abuse, it's worth noting that the lie needs to be material in order for a crime to have been committed.