News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by jvm_ on Monday February 03, 2020 @12:13PM (#22226251)
So, if I go to California with my NY cell phone and dial 911... I get the emergency services of the tower I connected to? Was always curious who I'd get when I'm not near home.
Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by RL_Quine on Monday February 03, 2020 @12:16PM (#22226270)
Yes. You can always make an emergency call, without service from your actual provided, and without a SIM card.
Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by jvm_ on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:11PM (#22227777)
But who answers? California 911 - because that's where I'm physically located. or NY 911 because that's where my phone is from?
Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by Keverw on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:26PM (#22229322)
Based on your location, but I know that there's stories about location not being accurate, remember seeing a report that some Pizza app and ride sharing apps can be more accurate. Someone told me on their cell phone 911 went to state's highway patrol instead of the city police, not sure if true or not since haven't had to dial 911 from a cell phone.

However if you have VOIP, not all VOIP providers support 911 but the ones that do want you to set a 911 address on your account itself, phone number or for a specific Analog telephone adapter - ATA Device from my understanding. I know our cable company provides phone service and the old modem had a sticker warning about VOIP and E911, not sure if the new one does or not since haven't looked at it too much.

Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by kempbellt on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:29PM (#22231002)
Just guessing based on how the technology works, but I would presume that when you initiate an emergency call via a cell phone call, the best location indicator that emergency services receive is "somewhere near tower X", since you are just making a voice call.

Apps running on the phone have access to your phone's GPS and can get more precise location data, if you have allowed it. Using an emergency app (Active911, Smart911, etc) will provide more specific location data to emergency services, but these are applications that rely on data and GPS to be working and may not work in as many situations as a simple 911 call.

As far as who receives the call, I imagine it is just based on who the tower is preconfigured to forward the call to. If the tower you are connected to is close to a highway, you'll probably get highway patrol. If you're in town, you'll probably get local police.

Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by gknoy on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:30PM (#22230558)
> I know that there's stories about location not being accurate

If possible, try to use a land line, because the emergency calls are often routed to a different location when made with a cellular phone. This may not be true everywhere, but at least where I live in northern CA cellular calls are routed in such a way that response time can be 20-30 minutes slower than if made via a land line. When experiencing cardiac arrest, the difference in minutes can have a profound effect.

Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by munk-a on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:18PM (#22227855)
California 911 - the fact that your phone is from NY is not only ignored but never referenced in the process - this isn't a great analogy but you could think of your cellphone as having a built-in walkie-talkie that it uses for emergency calls. All the mechanisms for making a normal phone call are discarded when you dial an emergency number. So, nowhere on the state diagram of making an emergency phone call, is the box that says "Tell the user to dial 1 before a long distance number" - they are two separate systems.
Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by anticensor on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @12:48AM (#22232796)
Routing code + emergency number does work in some countries as a normally billed emergency call. Some countries silently redirect emergency call into billing infrastructure too.
Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by singron on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:19PM (#22227858)
Last I heard, calling 911 from a mobile phone in CA tends to connect you to California Highway Patrol, who usually forward your call to a more local dispatcher. Some people recommend saving the emergency number for your local police department so you can skip that step.
Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by benburwell on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:04PM (#22229068)
This is how it works in most areas. Mobile calls to 911 will go to the PSAP for a relatively large region, who will triage the call and if your address is in an area served by a more local PSAP, they will add a calltaker from the local PSAP to the line and transfer the call to them.

It's probably best to just stick with 911. That's what calltakers are used to, and trying to route around 911 means you won't get the advantages built into that system (like priority handling, mapping, etc).

Re:Phone services disrupted across B.C., but emergency calls... by gpvos on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:20PM (#22229928)
Of course. Any other design would be braindamaged beyond belief.