And he leans into the craziness a bit beforehand by choosing to describe stuff in a way that sounds a bit unbelievable ("hoverslam onto a droneship" = land under constant deceleration on a barge with station-keeping thrusters... "bioweapon defense mode" = good air filters, "autopilot" = good lane-keeping like an airplane's autopilot), drawing scoffs from a lot of intelligent, serious people. ...which pays off in spades when the thing succeeds. So maybe that's a bit of marketing instinct, but not in the traditional sense.
So the more nonsensical he makes it sound, the greater the return when it actually happens.
He gets the scoffers to do his marketing for him.
I agree, but this is true only when things actually happen. How about his idea of using rockets instead of planes for long haul flight (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LENvGRsr7Q)? Or how about the hyperloop - any real progress on that? Or his idea of a submersible to save those kids trapped in a cave - was it good that he hyped that up? Remember when he started calling people pedophiles without proof?
I'm also curious if you have more details on his technical contributions to Tesla and SpaceX. Do you know to what extent he's actually involved in the work (design, engineering etc.)?
Hyperloop is making progress. It wasn't a priority for Musk; he didn't start a Hyperloop company, but open-sourced the idea and let others run with it. Those companies have kind of petered out for the most part. He did also start a student competition for Hyperloop, which IS continuing. There's a mile-long prototype vacuum tube outside SpaceX's headquarters where students tested pods going hundreds of miles per hour for several years (including 2019). He is now having a 10 kilometer long tube (with a turn) built to continue the competition and test speeds comparable to the original concept. He did start The Boring Company to try to address one of the main problems with Hyperloop (the extreme cost of boring tunnels), and that IS making progress. They're on-track (heh) for completion of tunnels in May for a mass transit system using pods (but at atmospheric pressure) based on stretched Tesla vehicles that will serve the Las Vegas convention center. Currently has dug about 3000ft of the first tunnel which is to be a bit more than a mile long.
The cave bit was embarrassing to Musk, he made some gross mistakes, and while the submersible folk were definitely trying to help (like NASA had developed capsules to rescue trapped miners in past disasters), the feedback of crazy between Musk and the media was more a liability than a help. He lost a lot of credibility with the name-calling, even though I definitely think he had been trying to help.
Musk is chief engineer at SpaceX, so he does similar systems engineering work as you'd expect for someone in his position. If you talk to people who have worked with him, they will tell you he has a good understanding and a deep technical involvement in both companies (especially SpaceX). Although that's hardly unique. I think the main strength is pursuing goals that are both important and challenging and empowering his employees to execute quickly on these challenges (and part of the reason he can empower them to act quickly is because he has enough technology knowledge to make command decisions on key technical questions which otherwise could end up in "analysis by paralysis" or even worse, continuing down a technical dead end just due to organizational inertia).
If at least the hyperloop project manages to get off the ground (pun sort of intended) that would still be a nice contribution to human progress.
I'm not at all sure about the long-haul rockets though. I think having rockets near population centers is extremely dangerous to begin with.
Secondly, I'm not sure the cost-benefit ratio makes sense. Transport aboard a rocket must be extremely expensive, but if you take the trip to/from the rocket-port into account the door-to-door time won't be spectacularly shorter than it is now.
But SpaceX intends to pursue fully and rapidly reusable rockets, which at least theoretically have the possibility of solving that problem by lowering launch prices by orders of magnitude, allowing greater improvement in reliability by returning the vehicles, and increasing the flight rates enough that you can prove out safety. I'm thinking probably a history of thousands or even tens of thousands of launches are necessary before the first point-to-point crewed launches (for specialized purposes, emergencies, charters) are feasible with reasonable safety, and maybe 100,000 or even a million launches before mass transit usage. Here's an article where a SpaceX representative addresses your exact point, i.e. safety of in-land launches of Starship and how many launches may be necessary to get to that point: https://www.businessinsider.com/spacex-one-million-starship-...
As far as door-to-door time, IMO, you would need to use like a seaplane or maybe an electric VTOL vehicle (or, heh, a Hyperloop) to get to the launch pad quick enough for the trip to be worth it.
As far as energy usage, such long-haul rocket flights may be roughly comparable to Concorde flights by my calculation (if they fill the vehicle up with high capacity seating... which may be a challenge if the tickets are business class prices), and the fuel is planned to eventually be made with the same carbon-neutral solar-to-gas technology (electrolysis of water, then the Sabatier Reaction) that is required for Starship on Mars (which, of course, has no natural gas deposits or free oxygen).
People were signing up to pay $200,000k to go into space on spaceship two. People will pay even more to go on an orbital flight. You can keep up the demand by decreasing the price for quite awhile, I would imagine. Unless the FAA gets in the way and just bans people from flying. Hopefully they won't as it would be purely voluntary and probably way less risky than wing-suit flying.
I don't doubt that crewed launches will happen before 100,000. But keep in mind that Starship 1) is supposed to be super cheap to fly with fast turnaround, so you can afford a bunch of test flights and 2) will be used for launching a bunch of stuff into orbit already. Falcon 9 will have nearly 100 launches before it launches Dragon Crew, and that one has a launch abort system. 3) Starship has no full abort system like Dragon, so you're going to have to rely on flight history.
Flying people on charter flights may be feasible earlier, as the risk tolerance for general aviation is MUCH higher.
Base jumping has a fatality rate of about 1 in 1000, so to get risk down to 1 in 1000, you're going to need around 500-1000 consecutive successful launches (OR a lot of incredibly expensive mission assurance engineering... honestly might be cheaper just to do hundreds of test launches!). Regular skydiving is MUCH safer at 1 fatality in 10,000 or 1 in 100,000.
I expect the lunar flyby will require a good 25 to 100 consecutive successful launches beforehand. Starlink is supposed to have up to 40,000 satellites eventually. Starship can do about 400 at a time, so that's 100 launches right there. (There's some confusion, there... some say the permit is actually for 12,000 satellites. But Starship is still expected to do a bunch of regular commercial launches, say about 15-20 flights per year in addition to Starlink).
Driving and general aviation (private planes) are much less safe per mile than general aviation. If a Starship flight is 10,000 miles, to be as safe as driving a car, it only needs to get to 1 fatality in 10,000. To get as safe as a private jet (which the rich and famous seem to have no problems using), it's about 1 fatality in 10,000 to 50,000.
If we just have to be as safe as taking a motorcycle for 10,000 miles, that's just 1 in 500, which is pretty doable for Starship.
I don’t agree. We already have maglev, is hyperloop going to be cheaper to build/operate? If not, why would the marginal speed increase prompt governments to invest in this kind of infrastructure vs. traditional rail or maglev? The problem is not that hyperloop won’t work, it’s that it is another gadgetbahn[1] that doesn’t make economic sense in a political climate where infrastructure investment is verboten.
Hyperloop's infrastructure cost is hopefully being solved by The Boring Company (although if they make more than incremental progress in tunneling efficiency, all sorts of tunnel projects in the US--which has particularly bad tunnel infrastructure costs--should improve). Also, if Hyperloop succeeds, it might help loosen the political restraints.
Personally, I think The Boring Company is more likely to be successful than Hyperloop itself. There's a lot of really hairy engineering required for super high speeds. BUT the Hyperloop student competition's 10km track could push the state of the art in rail speed, and that may have interesting consequences.
With fully reusable rockets, one gets to the point where they are better than airplanes because you can use them more (10 flights per day from Sydney to New York and back instead of the 1/2 round trip per day you currently get with airplanes). They cost similar amounts to build, but can make much more revenue/time. Also for long trips (1/2 way around the world) the fuel used/passenger will also be similar.
This is of course future tech, but could be coming in the next few years. Elon Musk say first orbital tests coming this year.
As fo the Earth-to-Earth Rocket plan, that’s based on Starship which is in development, and you can follow along live in the SpaceX subreddit.
As for calling people pedophiles, I am sure you have said equally terrible things about people who have insulted you or dismissed your work as useless.
He did was able to build a car company and a rocket company. Sure you found example that are less crazy than what he said, but you forget the actual crazy stuff he did.
I agree, any scenario where people are able to survive long term on Mars the same techniques should work on Earth given enough resources dedicated to implementing them. The main reason surviving Mars might be easier than a ravaged Earth is just the number of people, it'll be much harder on Earth because even if one particular country manages to setup something they'll be in competition with every other country for the resources to do it and the scale required will be bigger because of the number of people it would have to support.
There is one other reason to colonize Mars that isn't 'running away from a burning planet' and that's just as a kind of civilization backup against crazy civilization ending events (super-bug, meteor strike, complete climate collapse, etc.), note none of these need to completely wipe out human life to want an 'independent backup' civilization. Modern life can seem pretty fragile when you think about the long supply chains from raw material to finished product and the intricate machines/techniques that go into even relatively simple products.
I think it's the kind of thinking that partially comes from exposure to a lot of scifi and also the fact that very few things threaten billionaires beyond death (which I'm a little surprised more aren't pouring money into senescence research) and the break down of modern life. They're pretty secure against most everything else.
He is probably in the 99.99th percentile of engineers, but that still means there's many many thousands of engineers as smart as he is. However, he is also in the 99th percentile for marketing, 99.9th percentile in leadership, 99th percentile of celebrity, etc.
No, he is not special on any single dimension, but it is extremely rare to find this distribution, which is what he actually is and all these dimensions were used to make his companies successful.
I agree Elon is backed by incredibly smart and possibly overworked people and that contributes to his own reputation undeservedly, but he’s driven a company that has made more space progress than most of humanity. Let’s give him some credit on that front and let him spill his own cash on the crazy ideas at least. “Completely overrated” is a bit too far.
Benefiting from open-sourced research that was publicly funded (https://www.inverse.com/article/15272-nasa-releases-rocket-a...) probably also helped a little :))
Also don't forget that the US federal government is an important SpaceX client.
And yes, Nasa (and the DOD) are probably the most important customers of SpaceX... So? Its not like SpaceX are getting free money there. They are providing a service to the government, and getting paid for it - And providing that service at a lower cost than the government would bear if they did it themselves, and a lower cost than their competitors (I'm looking at Boeing - They are getting paid 60% more than SpaceX per seat for commercial crew flights to the ISS)
Also look into the Raptor engine SpaceX have developed. Its a key plank for their future mars ambitions. Its the most advanced rocket engine ever developed and SpaceX funded its development themselves.
The point of colonizing Mars (for Musk) is not to move there when Earth becomes inhabitable. It's too remove the single point of failure for the species that Earth currently represents.
With a self-sustainable (even if harsh) Mars colony, a nuclear war on Earth no longer necessarily means the end of humanity.
How realistic is this self-sustainability? Where any moderately complex spare parts can be produced on Mars, instead of having to be supplied from Earth with yet another ultra-expensive supplies mission?
Imho we are talking hundreds of years here. Until then our burning home base Earth remains a single point of failure. Better douse the fire first.
Until then putting some people on Mars as a symbolic gesture to show humanity is still capable of grand achievements may be fine, esp. if that gives us hope we can tackle our other more immediate problems (though for me that is not needed).
So we are already hundreds of years late, aren't we? Let's start right now to make this happen.
> Better douse the fire first.
Here we are again... the good old, well there's something else wrong, lets just fix that other thing wrong and ignore everything else.
Why not working on both? What stop us from working on both? I would be happy to be wrong, but I'm pretty sure that you could do more to "douse the fire". We sadly can't stop doing 100% of what we do to fix everything.
I'm just speculating now, but I think this might be one reason Musk is so interested in robotic manufacturing (e.g. the failed "alien dreadnought" vision for the Model 3 production line). If you have mostly automated, flexible manufacturing systems that can be computer controlled and require minimal human expertise to operate then all you need is the computer files for whatever spare part you need to build. Set up 3-4 of these manufacturing centers at different spots for redundancy and you don't have to worry so much about spare part availability.
The first effort (Model 3 assembly) was a disaster though.
At least in terms of radiation, living on Mars seems less likely to be survivable than a nuclear war on Earth since fallout decays away but the space-based radiation bathing Mars is moderately high and permanent. See: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/life-unbounded/death-on...
Fair point. However it's sad to think that as a species we're so petty and narrow-minded that we need a backup in case we fuck this planet up ourselves. Maybe I'm too harsh, but I almost feel that we don't even deserve a backup if we can't avoid a nuclear holocaust or environmental collapse here on Earth.
https://phys.org/news/2017-03-nasa-magnetic-shield-mars-atmo...
Your question is premature because you're comparing the Earth of today to the Mars of today.
The short-term goal (short in the grand scheme of things, that is) is to build a colony on Mars that can satisfy the first level of Maslow's hierarchy: air, food, water, shelter. After that, moving to Mars will be a much more attractive prospect to a non-negligible number of people.
What is the timescale you have in mind? Hundreds, thousands of years? If this is the case, it makes more sense focusing on keeping Earth livable.
I think Kim Stanley Robinson had a nice take on this in "Aurora" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aurora_(novel)). Without giving too much away, one of the core ideas of the novel is that there really is no place like home.
> After that, moving to Mars will be a much more attractive prospect to a non-negligible number of people.
Hmm, what makes you think that? Again, how bad should Earth get before living in a place where you can't go outside is a better option?
Expanding beyond Earth is something we must do eventually. If we can do it now, why wait? We risk that we are unable to do it later.
[0] Beyond that I'm increasingly skeptical of any attempts to draw parallels or inferences from evolution about humans today because so much like evo-psych turns into unfounded garbage. Once a species gets to the point it can manipulate it's own environment and mortality evolution gets shaky as a framework.
[1] Simpler atomic components and resources could be mined on Mars where they couldn't in space so I'm allowing for some basic supplements extracted on Mars.
More importantly, there just isn’t enough reason to bother doing it aside from satisfying the Edmund Hillary “because it’s there” urge.
If you want more space to live, you’d be better off investing in women’s health and education so long run population trends can go down here in Earth.
If you want natural resources, you’d be better off figuring out how to mine asteroids so you don’t need to contend with overcoming a planetary gravity well to get them home.
If you want to push the envelope with terraforming, you’d be better off focusing on ambitious plans for carbon sequestration on Earth.
If you want to engineer us out of the “all our eggs in one planetary basket” problem, you probably want to first build permanent stations in outer space that are as self-sustaining as possible since those technologies will be foundational for both a Mars colony AND for building generation ships.
Basically, there are much more useful and generalizable technologies you can throw money at than a pointless Mars colony. I don’t get the obsession with that over everything else.
I think it may be more likely to happen somewhere with gravity just given how much development still needs to be done to extract materials out of asteroids. There's a lot to work through in being able to refine stuff like metals in micro gravity that hasn't even started yet.
If history is any judge though we'll go to Mars long before it's really viable simply because it's there. Hopefully not too many people get caught up in it.
[0] Unless it's turns out to be viable to bake similar resources out of lunar regolith. I haven't read deeply enough to see if that's just SciFi or a viable source of the basic elementals needed to support a settlement.
[-1] edit: To clarify here I mean on Mars for consumption on Mars of course. Though Mar's much thinner atmosphere would also make some more exotic launch technologies potentially viable. eg: a rail/coil gun launch to a skyhook maybe given the much lower atmospheric drag it would experience.
Well, sort of. Most of these aren't as convenient as they sound. Gravity is only about 40% of Earth's IIRC, so if you had humans there you'd still be contending with loss of muscle and bone density. If we're talking about ambitious future technology I think a spinning wheel station is probably a more stable way to keep people healthy. Plus you have to contend with seasons and weather. Wind, dust, wild temperature swings and all the extra wear on materials you will get as a result. . .
It would also take forever to actually thicken up the atmosphere, so you would probably want to be careful how much you go pulling CO2 out of the air to grow plants if long-term viability is your priority. As for mining, locality is a big help, especially if you're going to be remote-controlling drones, but contending with landing/taking-off on a planet is a huge logistical expense. Particularly if you're dealing with lots of heavy machinery for mining.
In either location the initial construction will be very intensive/expensive in space you need to launch or refine and assemble vast amounts of material where on Mars there's the option of a small starter base while you dig tunnels out for the main living quarters. [0]
Either path is definitely difficult I'm just trying to highlight the ways Mars is less of a leap because it's another planet and we don't have to reinvent the wheel when it comes to things like extracting and refining metals or every single industrial process that makes the modern world tick.
> It would also take forever to actually thicken up the atmosphere, so you would probably want to be careful how much you go pulling CO2 out of the air to grow plants if long-term viability is your priority.
I don't think this is actually a huge concern making the atmosphere livable without a suit will take an incredible amount of engineering and like on Earth while we're talking about raw elemental materials the amount humans can possibly use pales in comparison to the amount available. [1] Any project like that will dwarf anything we've done to date.
[0] With several intermediate steps like building habitats out of processed rocks from the surface for example.
[1] There are rare exceptions I know of like Helium where the main issue is still cheap supply not actually running out.
You could make a similar case for Asteroid mining. There are plenty of resources up there.
Sure. But does it make sense to rely on this as a realistic Plan B to an Earth destroyed by global warming?
Fort Bridger, Wyoming has a population of 345[0]. California has a population of nearly 40 million[1]. Should those crazy people of the 19th century never have bothered with Fort Bridger?
Inhabiting a habitable planet outside our solar system is so far beyond our current capabilities that there is no point putting any money in to it.
Any kind of foothold on a second planet within our solar system would change that reality. Routine travel between Earth and Mars would provide heaps and heaps of experience and capability. It would make any discussion of colonizing outside our solar system much more reasonable than it is today.
Inhabiting Mars was never the end goal. It just happens to be the most practical one in a much much much larger picture.
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fort_Bridger,_Wyoming 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California
Human skills to breathe and find sustenance below the ocean surface have been common enough for 70+ years. Do you really require that we wait millenia before we try it on another planet?
they have already got very bad - the conservative anti-progress people are running the show more and more, and by means of SpaceX and Tesla Musk is saving our civilization from the main danger for a technological civilization, the danger of being completely overtaken by the conservative anti-progress people.
LOL. If the New World is any indication, as soon as there's money to be made or persecution to escape (which we are not out of).
But is there money to be made on Mars (that could not be made with robots)? Also, I suspect that the people who are currently being persecuted (e.g. Uyghurs in China) won't be in a position to leave Earth any time soon (e.g. in the next 100 years).
Still, even if both things end up happening, this is still not the same as having Mars as a plan B for Earth.
I think you again need to look to the example of the New World. The Pilgrims were not persecuted like the Uyghurs. They were relatively well off English folk living in the Netherlands who felt that their laws were overly restrictive and prevented the free practice of their religion.
Thus, groups highly likely to colonize Mars would be traditionalist Catholics, evangelical Christians, and maybe some new age movements. These feel like the current system is persecuting them, but still have enough werewithal and freedom to be able to choose to move. That, and their respective philosophies encourage exploration. It is highly unlikely that any group that decided to move because of persecution would be a racial or ethnic one.
Going to Mars makes a lot of sense to some fairly capable folk. Getting there, and sustaining life, is going to be hard.
But, we will make it easier eventually. I can think of a way we could turn Earth into a recovering paradise, full of natural wonder, and it would definitely involve using Mars to fix it.
Understand those motivations and you'll understand why in the current century nowhere on Earth is as appealing as Mars for satisfying the needs that previously could have been satisfied by going a bit further west. The environmental challenges of the journey and the destination will be great, yes, but the payoff will be indescribably (if you don't understand those motivations at an emotional level) worth it for those who meet the challenges.
That being said, the GP doesn't actually provide any evidence, hence there's not much to refute.
It’s amazing to me that people don’t see the parallels, the silver spoon childhood under a ruthless father breeding an unbounded narcissism and entitlement that must be fed with marketing spectacles, social media battles, and young women.
I guess people love them both because it’s all so quintessentially American.
I think he's nowhere near the level of people that we usually think of as geniuses. In certain ways he's good at marketing and hyping things up, but a lot of his ideas, especially the Mars one, are nonsensical.
Just try to think about this: how bad do the conditions on Earth have to get before it makes sense to try to move to a planet that is essentially uninhabitable? Where even in the best scenarios we would live really harsh lives after a long and dangerous voyage.