News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by 34679 on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:29AM (#22224961)
> there is no future event that would make earth as uninhabitable as Mars is today.

Wouldn't that imply if we can make Mars habitable, then we'll be capable of dealing with whatever problems arise here on Earth? Think of it as a nice test run without the immediate fate of humanity's only biosphere at stake.

Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by AndrewKemendo on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:34AM (#22225013)
The costs involved in turning Mars into an experimental environment, call it a "twin", would likely eclipse the sum total of human activity to date (300k years worth) by several orders of magnitude.
Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by 34679 on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:45AM (#22225106)
That's fine, unless we have something better to do. If it takes 10,000 years or 100,000 years, it doesn't matter, unless the work being done is detracting from more important work. Many people, myself included, would struggle to think of more impactful goals for humanity to accomplish. Feeding, clothing, and housing everyone would be nice, but those things are still far more personal than any project that aims to prolong our very existence as a species.
Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by cgriswald on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:03AM (#22225330)
It's nearly impossible to define 'something better to do.' Solutions to Martian needs could have applicability to problems here on Earth. Feeding, clothing, and housing are definitely problems Martians would have. What lessons might be learned in their relatively small, closed ecosystem that we're completely blind to here with Earth's abundance?

In my personal opinion, if humanity has any purpose or meaning at all, it's to spread Earth life. For all the faux human exceptionalism people like to extol, the one thing we can do that no other life form can do at any scale, is spread Earth life. (Panspermia seems incredibly unlikely to me and probably requires a near-perfect match between initial conditions on the planet and the organism(s) that happen to find themselves there.)

Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by leetcrew on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:06AM (#22225388)
why care about the long-term existence of our species? certainly we should strive to leave a better world for our children, their children, and their children's children, but past a certain point it seems very abstract to me. even 10,000 years is about three times as long as the totality of recorded history. in 100,000 years, our genome may have diverged enough that whatever humans live at that point in the future wouldn't be the same species anyway. why should I, a sentient sack of meat living in the year 2020 care about these things? more to the point: why should I sacrifice improving the lives of any currently living beings for the sake of ones that may live in future millennia?
Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by UnFleshedOne on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:50PM (#22228205)
You can tell that to the Biomaterial Processing Courts when they queue you up for utilization for the betterment of humanity. But for now I don't think anybody asks you to personally care about anything, much less do anything.

Or would you like to ask somebody else to work on things you do care about?

Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by AndrewKemendo on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:59AM (#22225298)
I argue we should be building a more capable and survivable successor to biological intelligence that can survive beyond traditional biological extinction periods (M of years).
Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by cgriswald on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:17AM (#22225518)
It's a bit of a false dichotomy to suggest we have to choose between the two, but...

If we must choose, we should choose to colonize Mars. Statistically speaking, an asteroid impact is inevitable. Time is the relevant variable. The sooner humanity can be a multi-world species, the sooner we are more robust against that threat. The same will be true of our successors who will necessarily have less time than we to spread from Earth. If we manage to spread to other worlds and Earth is destroyed, we will still be around to develop our successors (and will also have a leg up on spreading to ever more worlds). If we manage to create our successors and the Earth is destroyed before we get to other worlds, it's game over.

Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by AndrewKemendo on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:41AM (#22225837)
You're just re-stating the original argument for colinization (an asteroid/event would make the earth less inhabitable than mars is currently) that I disagree with and originally addressed.
Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by cgriswald on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:33PM (#22228026)
I don't think so. For most asteroid impacts, we wouldn't even need to build subterranean shelters for the species to survive. It isn't enough for the species to survive. Our civilization, particularly our very technological civilization, must survive as well. Without such a civilization, we'll be trapped here until the Earth itself dies. Our long term survival depends on the short term survival of our civilization.

The relative habitability of Earth and Mars may actually have a converse effect on the survival of a technological civilization. On Mars, such a civilization would be necessary for continued individual survival for what may be geological time scales. On a recovering Earth, humans may salvage civilization, devolve into a new and indefinite dark ages, or give up on civilization entirely and the species will still go on.

Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by keanzu on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:46AM (#22225132)
The sum total of human activity in the last 100 years also eclipses the sum total of all human activity prior (300k years worth). Humanity didn't do a lot for a long time.

But yes, Mars would be a mega project. Isaac Arthur does great stuff on Youtube which gives an idea of the magnitude of the works necessary.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kmFOBoy2MZ8

Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by dwild on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:24PM (#22229973)
> The costs involved in turning Mars into an experimental environment

I think it would be more realistic to say, if we are able to live on Mars instead of making Mars livable. Being able to live on Mars won't require "the sum total of human activity to date (300k years worth)"

Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by hfourm on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:49AM (#22225176)
I guess that makes sense, and by most measures makes it seem "impossible".

But the flip side is, why not? What else do we have to do...

Re:James Lovelock: 'I Would Not Waste My Fortune on Colonizi... by gbrown on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:42AM (#22225850)
> Wouldn't that imply if we can make Mars habitable

We can't (excluding domes etc.). We won't be able to unless we acquire such powerful planetary engineering technology that we could much more easily build enormous orbital cities complete with functioning biospheres.

It may work to live in enclosed environments on Mars, but the scale of actually terraforming it puts it in the realm of fantasy.