Having said that, the reality remains that, even without the models, the CO2 levels are increasing, they are well correlated to temperature increases, and they are expected to increase further - so VERY PROBABLY - climate change is a very serious massive problem. This is all true even without the models.
When it comes to the reliability of models, the devil is in the details. ...but, of course, no one should assume that a model turning out to be wrong or biased suddenly negates all the other evidence we have. Models are just one piece of a probability decision tree we need to navigate.
Does "they" refer to all models?
The main article's set of models are different than the ones referred to in another link someone in this thread provided, and I suspect the article you've linked will also use yet another unique set.
If it was me trying to persuade people, and all historic climate change models did indeed work really, really well, I'd make an authoritative web page that lists all of these models including their inputs and outputs, and show a detailed quantitative comparison of their outputs. I would think this approach would be more persuasive in multiple ways than hundreds of separate articles written in a narrative style, lacking numbers and consistency in sets of models.
I don't think any intellectually honest person is indifferent to this bet. Everyone believes there is a solid chance that the climate is actually getting warmer, and almost no one would wager serious money at even odds on a globally colder 2021.
If you wouldn't bet against the climate getting warmer, then I don't think you have any place calling yourself a "climate change skeptic"
In a similar vein, I invest in index funds because I'm not a market skeptic. The market (at the moment) tends to grow year over year. I put my money where my mouth is in the market, I'd do the same on global temperature, and I'd win (on average, if I bet year over year, unless something changes dramatically).
The climate isn't getting warmer or colder just because next year's temperature does.
What makes such a measurement an "invalid form"?
The measurements are real, and there is an established history of the models being generally correct (if not in specific details) by now. Climate study is not the new science you seem to think it is.
Can you point me to one such model? One that actually predicted temperatures correctly back in the 1970s and not after various recent "adaptations" like "corrected" emission data?
> The measurements are real
Yes, measurements are real. Interpolations, resulting "global" temperatures and predictions aren't.
HadCRUT4 (from UK Met Office Hadley Centre and the University of East Anglia’s Climatic Research Unit)
GISTEMP from the NASA GISS
MLOST from the NOAA
JMA from the Japan Meteorological Agency
I'm open to other datasets. I'm not choosy.
I believe that the noisy measure goes up, on average, because it is (noisily) measuring a warming climate. I'll make that bet every year, and I will come out ahead...
using the trend line, you could set odds at which the betting on a colder 2021 would be the correct bet - but it isn't 50/50, which it would be if the process were random noise.
as a professional poker player I'm not surprised by this argument, but I am saddened.
edit: do you actually not understand the basics of statistical inference? this is like, middle-level high school math.
Good luck with that, but you first asked about one year (next year), which is a different matter altogether.
> (edit: do you actually not understand the basics of statistical inference? this is like, middle-level high school math.
I completely understand your point and how you are trying to move the goalpost from an easily refutable argument to something more useful. Perhaps your "professional poker player" mind doesn't understand that recent increases/decreases in temperature averages affect next year's weather, whereas past poker games don't affect your current one.
We don't need any climate models to know that Earth is warming. We can tell that just from what we know of: how electromagnetic radiation works, the basic thermodynamics of gases, determining isotope ratios of the carbon making up a sample of CO2, how much solar energy falls on the Earth, the mechanisms by which energy can leave the Earth, the amount of energy leaving Earth as measured by satellites.
That's enough to allow verifying that:
(1) a net heating of the Earth taking place,
(2) this is mostly caused by humans (mostly be emission of greenhouse gases from fossil fuels) (and yes, we can tell the difference because emissions from burning fossil fuels have a different carbon isotope ratio than other sources), and
(3) it is getting more extreme.
All you need climate models for is to try to figure out where the extra heat will end up and what it will do there.
Start here: https://skepticalscience.com/empirical-evidence-for-co2-enha...
Then proceed to intermediate and advanced. There are a TON of citations for your perusal. After your are done with that, the comments have some additional insights.
Have fun. This is quite the rabbit hole to dive into.
What was the CO2 ppm in the early Holocene? Why was the early Holocene so much warmer than today in spite of lower CO2 concentrations?
Early Holocene Temperature Oscillations Exceed Amplitude of Observed and Projected Warming in Svalbard Lakes
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/201...
Here's one of them from that page, chosen at random: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.5589/m04-044
A blog page linking a bunch of academic papers is as good as a hackernews comment linking a bunch of academic papers.
Your linked paper is about arctic temperatures, not global average temperatures.
You don't have to believe the models:
The models differ in the scale of how bad it's going to be, not on whether it's going to be bad. Your stance is kind of like saying "Well doc, you're telling me I have sepsis, but you can't tell me how bad that's going to be so I'm refusing treatment until you can improve your models."
Climate change is happening right now, with effects that are observable as trends across the globe. Even the most optimistic model is predicting widespread catastrophe.
Pascal's wager has no information. You know nothing of the state of god's existence.
The precautionary principle uses current equalibrium as the default.
The current working equalibrium embeds information.
The precautionary principle does not state it will result in the best outcome. Only that it's more likely to not have the worst.
If I throw a ball to you, your ability to put your hand approximately where it's going to be and catch it is "extrapolation based on very complex and interconnected inputs," and as it gets closer you're able to improve based on additional input.
Sure the models could all be wrong, we could be on the brink of a new ice age, and that ball could suddenly take a sharp right turn and accelerate. I wouldn't recommend putting all your money on either of those as a bet.
Climate is a physical phenomenon which can be modeled. One problem is that humans have an effect on the climate, so models can't predict how much effort humanity is going to put into averting that change. Since that aspect can't be modeled, they produce different projections for multiple cases of human behavior: business as usual, modest efforts to change, aggressive efforts to change.
In realize, we need fewer cars, more trains, better transport options, cell phones that last 8 years and that are repairable rather than 1.5 year planned obsolescence Internet of Trash devices.
The debate over climate/CO2 is a religious ideology at this point, and a very unhelpful one at that.
The article talks about it a little bit about how the models are used to predict the 19th century to see if they are correct. But the models use the last 100 years as input so of course it will give you accurate output. But the real challenge of the models would be to accurately predict things that are not part of the inputs into the model. I don’t believe that these models can do this and are thus an exercise in straight extrapolation based on very complex and interconnected inputs.