Neuroscientists are being descriptive, not proscriptive, when they tell you what areas of the brain are for what. They aren't "deciding" what it means, they are telling you that across a wide range of people, when they see activity X, brain part Y lights up. That the brain might be significantly differently organized if bits of it are missing is hardly a groundbreaking idea, nor even remotely shocking to actual scientists. The brain reconfiguring itself, even in adults, has been repeatedly observed, with vision cortexes replaced by audio processing after becoming blind and so forth. This is interesting, but the "phrenologists" aren't going to be sent into a tizzy because of this one specific case. Your conception of the science might be sent into a tizzy, but that's not the scientist's problem. (Well, at least not directly.)
Re:Child With Missing Cerebellum Shows Power of Human Spirit
by jerf on Tuesday February 15, 2011 @12:04PM
(#2222046)
I find it a bit frustrating when people accuse scientists of being behind the game, because their own conception of the state of the science based on the state-of-the-art in 1960 mixed with popsci crap can't deal with a result.
Re:Child With Missing Cerebellum Shows Power of Human Spirit
by transfabulator on Monday February 21, 2011 @12:34PM
(#2246264)
Good point. I do wish the neuroscientists concerned would be more active drawing the distinction that you have made.
This part of the brain is for X, here is the Y-centre, here is where Z is controlled.
Except, wait, XYZ are missing :-o