News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The real world is mutable – consequences for system design by TeMPOraL on Saturday February 01, 2020 @03:59PM (#22213186)
No, it isn't.

>The reality of life is that the real world is not immutable. I mean that at two levels. The first is that sometimes people make mistakes and publish things that they very strongly wish and need to change or retract. Pretending that they do not is ignoring reality. Beyond that, things in the real world are almost always mutable and removable because lawyers can show up on your doorstep with a court order to make them so

That's not about what the world is. That's what some people think it should be, and systems (e.g. legal systems) have been created on top of real world to feature this mutability.

Real world is immutable with respect to time. What happened, happened; you can't change it without a time machine. You can't just unpublish something, you have to actively work to destroy all practically accesible traces of it (and fight the people with interest in preserving these traces).

So a better, more accurate way of phrasing GP's point would be: systems designed by humans are mutable by design. Physical reality is immutable with respect to time and causality.

Re:The real world is mutable – consequences for system design by seanmcdirmid on Saturday February 01, 2020 @04:35PM (#22213413)
> Real world is immutable with respect to time. What happened, happened; you can't change it without a time machine. You can't just unpublish something, you have to actively work to destroy all practically accesible traces of it (and fight the people with interest in preserving these traces).

That definition doesn't make any sense. Mutability necessarily requires time to drive a change - no time passing, no mutation. Also, you are claiming that immutability is equivalent to irreversibility and the arrow of time, which I also think is a bit wonky.

Re:The real world is mutable – consequences for system design by TeMPOraL on Saturday February 01, 2020 @05:29PM (#22213679)
> Mutability necessarily requires time to drive a change - no time passing, no mutation.

The time that's required for mutability is the real time, the time outside of the system considered. You can mutate events recorded within a system. You can't unhappen events themselves.

> Also, you are claiming that immutability is equivalent to irreversibility and the arrow of time, which I also think is a bit wonky.

Actually, immutability is even more evident without the arrow of time; if world(t+1) = f(world(t)), then world(t) = f^-1(world(t+1)); f and f^-1 are themselves immutable.

Re:The real world is mutable – consequences for system design by taeric on Saturday February 01, 2020 @04:22PM (#22213331)
This is silly, though. Yes, facts can be thought of as stationary in time. No, no system is stationary in time. Even the ground you are on is moving.

So, can you record facts against time in your database? I mean, go for it. Might even be useful in many realms. Doesn't magically make you able to operate on something frozen in time, though.

Re:The real world is mutable – consequences for system design by skybrian on Saturday February 01, 2020 @04:29PM (#22213368)
It seems like the opposite is true of verbal communication? If it wasn't recorded, there is rarely evidence of what was said for someone else to find.

Although there is often some evidence, it's unusual for a complete history of an event to be preserved in perfect fidelity, as it's sometimes modeled in a computer.

Re:The real world is mutable – consequences for system design by TeMPOraL on Saturday February 01, 2020 @05:36PM (#22213706)
> If it wasn't recorded, there is rarely evidence of what was said for someone else to find.

There are rarely "practically accessible traces" present. But the information about what was said itself radiates at the speed of light. There may be evidence present for a dedicated enough investigator. But even more important is the obvious - you can't just unsay what you said. When you say something to someone, you change their state. They'll remember what you said, or what they felt. You can't roll that back.

> Although there is often some evidence, it's unusual for a complete history of an event to be preserved in perfect fidelity, as it's sometimes modeled in a computer.

It is a qualitative change on the social level; it's absolutely not a change at all on the physics/causality level.

Mutability works in human-designed systems. For instance, if I say something to you, and there was no recording of it, then I can later deny we talked, and from the legal point of view - a point of view of an artificial system built on top of physical reality - the conversation did not happen. This doesn't change that a) it did, and b) both of us know it did.

Re:The real world is mutable – consequences for system design by skybrian on Saturday February 01, 2020 @07:40PM (#22214326)
Yes, many things can't be unsaid, but it's still going too far to say that we know what happened. Human memory is far from reliable, so we don't necessarily know or agree on what happened. This is assuming the listener even heard it correctly.