News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I had to get a background check for my job; the report is... by coldtea on Saturday February 01, 2020 @02:03PM (#22212481)
>There were plenty of claimed religious justifications for businesses who wanted to discriminate against mixed race couples, but in the end, that didn't really matter. There is no functional difference between bigotry with "nuance" and bigotry itself.

Sure, there's "no functional difference between bigotry with "nuance" and bigotry itself". But here the word bigotry is used twice in a weaselly way, making it a circular argument, that assumes what it should instead prove.

There's, however, a functional difference between bigotry and a nuanced position that touches on sex/race/etc relations - which was my point.

Except if nobody can have a position in sex/race/etc matters that goes against what an enlightened minority holds, except if they are bigots. Even if there are members of said sex, race, etc agree with the person -- and the "enlightened minority" is often a self-appointed hodgepodge of noise-making people.

Re:I had to get a background check for my job; the report is... by coldtea on Saturday February 01, 2020 @08:50PM (#22214615)
Clarifying a little what I meant by my last paragraph, as it was hastily written - and also had a few typos:

My point is that there's a functional difference between bigotry and a nuanced position that touches on sex/race/etc relations - and that the latter does exist, and is often called out unfairly.

Now, one might believe that such a nuanced position is impossible to exist (without being bigotry).

That is, one might believe that nobody can have a stance on a matter concerning sex/race/etc that goes against what some enlightened minority holds, without being a bigot.

I try to point that this is wrong, via reduction ad absurdum.

And my first argument is: there are opinions called out as bigotry which some of the members of the group they reference also hold (e.g. saying something about group X which some X also believe, and being called a bigot about it).

If one doesn't believe that those opinions are nuanced, and not necessarily bigotry, then they should also accuse those members of group X as bigoted against themselves - which is absurd.

My second argument is: why would one believe that an accusation of bigotry can't be off? Especially since any random person/mob can make such accusations, for whatever purposes, and with whatever faulty reasoning -- and not only some ultimate arbiters of truth.

Re:I had to get a background check for my job; the report is... by Aloha on Sunday February 02, 2020 @02:09AM (#22215621)
I thought this line "Even if there are members of said sex, race, etc agree with the person -- and the "enlightened minority" is often a self-appointed hodgepodge of noise-making people." was rather brilliant.