Re:The EARN IT Act: how to ban end-to-end encryption without...
by samatman on Friday January 31, 2020 @08:24PM
(#22207841)
This is a cogent argument for having a ceremonial and practical/executive head of state, but doesn't even touch on why a hereditary monarch is in any way superior to having a ceremonial President and executive Prime Minister, as is common in other countries.
Re:The EARN IT Act: how to ban end-to-end encryption without...
by tialaramex on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:23PM
(#22208146)
Mmm? I covered that, it's about legitimacy.
The monarch plainly has no legitimacy whatsoever, there's no merit, nobody elected them, they were born into the job.
In contrast an elected President can use the ceremonial position to seize actual power. This isn't even just theoretical, it's an actual problem - or I guess if you've just used it to seize power, a brilliant feature...
Anyway, we don't want that, so the monarch is better.
As a result they also have zero democratic legitimacy, which is good because obviously as figurehead they'd otherwise be in an excellent position to seize actual power, which is the last thing you'd want to happen.
As to why prohibited, the temptation is, as you see in the present job of President of the United States to combine the two. Rather than ask people to resist this temptation, just prohibit it up front. These roles are huge asks, in terms both of the skills needed (or at least which ought to be needed) and the burden of responsibility. It would be easy to underestimate the figurehead role in particular, but it just isn't easy to be a symbol for hundreds of millions of people. So, de-risk by insisting on two people for two roles and never merging the role.