And the protocol spec page is fantastic: https://ssbc.github.io/scuttlebutt-protocol-guide/
... that said, it has some enormous problems around multi-device, rather costly replication (start at the beginning, catch up to now, otherwise you can't verify anything), and it's fairly normal to miss part of a conversation and not have any real way to get it filled in. There are a number of branching concepts with semi-compatible protocols that strike me as a lot more promising, but odds seem pretty good that the community will shift if necessary (which is a good thing).
Worth a shot for anyone to explore if they're curious though, there's even a largely-functional mobile app: https://www.manyver.se/
Also, append only => no deletes, correct?
This is something that will probably take some puzzling to get to a sustainable mechanism. The strategy I've heard talked about most often is to append metadata that marks it as 'deleted', so when things populate or 'gossip' further, it won't show up in the user interface. Instead it's labeled as 'archived' or 'deleted', or has a link to it's replacement.
Also, how much you download is related to how many people you follow, and text doesn't take up a ton of space.
As for text not taking up a ton of space. Sure. Except it's text with it's metadata, and possibly text generated by a few hundred people.
A friend and I managed to exchange ~24k messages on Slack over the last 3 years (~4k each / year); using it like some kind of "private twitter" where we would just post anything that might be of interest to the other.
What would it be like if I follow 300 or 1000 people doing the same, over Secure Scuttlebutt?
- At 1 byte per character (from what I've gathered, Unicode characters actually take up 1 to 4 bytes) - 140 characters / message (because Twitter proved it's usually enough) - messages' metadata (50 bytes?) - 4.000 messages / user / year - following 300 people
We'd get... 228MB / year?
That's actually way less than I expected!
I wasn't even worrying about the legality of it. Simply that you end up lugging those messages around on your devices.
And better be careful about what you post, because there's no taking it back.
“Secure Scuttlebutt (SSB) is a peer-to peer communication protocol, mesh network, and self-hosted social media ecosystem. Each user hosts their own content and the content of the peers they follow, which provides fault tolerance and eventual consistency.[5] Messages are digitally signed and added to an append-only list of messages published by an author.[6] SSB is primarily used for implementing distributed social networks, and utilizes cryptography to assure that content remains unforged as it is propagated through the network.”
Read more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secure_Scuttlebutt
Join us! There is a fully functioning client, and bustling Solarpunk community: http://scuttlebutt.nz