Re:Show HN: Regex Cheatsheet
by wahern on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:36AM
(#22202491)
Maybe it's easier to remember that lookbehinds are evil from an implementation standpoint, and even in Perl have arbitrary limitations. If you see lookbehinds, look away! If you see lookaheads, go ahead.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Oddly, lookbehinds are evil only in a specific backtracking world. We never got around to implementing arbitrary lookarounds in Hyperscan (https://github.com/intel/hyperscan) but if we had done something in the automata world to handle lookaround, lookbehinds are way easier than lookaheads.
To handle a lookbehind, you really only need to occasionally 'AND' together some states (not an operation you would normally do in a standard NFA whether Glushkov or Thompson). To handle lookaheads... well, it gets ugly.
Even for non-fixed length expressions?
Variable-length backward asserts are fine in automata-land, which is a bit peculiar.
It's something I really like about .NET's regular expressions. Lookbehind has no limitations and will just match backwards with all features you can use in other parts.
So depending on the language or flavor you're working in, running away isn't really necessary.
Re:Show HN: Regex Cheatsheet
by lonelappde on Friday January 31, 2020 @05:56PM
(#22206800)
Lookbehinds stay behind.