http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12114036
The Heart Protection Study (HPS) randomly assigned 20,536 subjects to simvastatin (40 mg/day) or placebo
After an average follow-up of 5.5 years, the following significant benefits with simvastatin were observed:
- A 13 percent reduction in all-cause mortality (12.9 versus 14.7 percent for placebo).
- An 18 percent reduction in deaths from heart disease or related blood vessel disease (5.7 versus 6.9 percent).
- A 24 percent reduction in major cardiovascular events (19.8 versus 25.2 percent)
- A 25 percent reduction in the first event rate for stroke (4.3 versus 5.7 percent) reflecting a 28 percent decrease in ischemic strokes and no reduction in hemorrhagic strokes
- Among 3982 diabetics without prior cardiovascular disease, a 28 percent reduction in the incidence of MI and stroke (14 versus 18.7 percent).
And I think I've seen this methodologically refuted elsewhere. Some studies have definitely got the opposite result.
Sure, the protocol for Advanced Cardiac Life support changes every 2 years, because some therapies that we use to thing were very effective, are proven to be less effective than new ones. But, there is a strong self-corrective factor in Medicine. The ideal isn't to do what the pharma companies push the doctors to do. The ideal is to do whatever the best science says increases lifespan, quality of life and decreases morbidity and mortality.
At times, studies are funded by pharma companies, and the research is tainted. Current best practices are a moving target, because the science changes. But, over all, good medical practice is a big plus.
Sure there are drugs that have great promise, are pushed through FDA approval and then are found to have bad side effects and/or not as effective as once thought... (e.g. Vioxx, Celebrex... both recalled several years after approval).
But, for every drug that isn't effective, or has bad complications, there are dozens that do work. And, many more are found to have other beneficial uses. For example, mucomyst is a drug that was developed to help break up mucous plugs in people's lungs. Then, is was found to work as the antidote for one of the most common and toxic poisonings: tylenol. It's also used to protect people's kidney's during IV contrast injections.
I'm sorry but the anti-pharma, anti-vaccination stuff that flies around the internet is one of the clearest examples of FUD I've seen, and it's very harmful. I've seen a number of people die because they didn't trust medicine and they didn't trust doctors. Please, check what you are saying before someone gets permanently hurt by your ideas.
If a diabetic doesn't take insulin or their anti-high-blood-sugar pills, where do they end up? The ER in a diabetic coma. A daily dose of insulin is like $1 a day. An ER visit/ICU hospitalization for a diabetic coma is around $20-50k depending on the severity.
If an asthmatic doesn't manage their chronic condition with the appropriate inhalers, where do they end up? The ER. IF they let it go too long, they end up on life support in the ICU.
Pneumonia used to be a leading cause of death, now it's not. Why? Antibiotics and oxygen therapy. People used to get polio all the time. I haven't seen an active case of polio every in my 15 year nursing career. Why? The polio vaccine.
The incidence of tetanus has dropped from 600,000 deaths in '92 to less than 150,000 deaths world wide. Why? The tetanus vaccine. Ref: http://www.emedicine.com/emerg/topic574.htm
Please, stop saying the pharmacology doesn't work. It does. It saves lives. Are there problems with the system? Sure. But please stop spreading FUD about "Big Pharma".
What do you think of this paper on iatrogenic deaths?
http://www.ourcivilisation.com/medicine/usamed.htm
I ask as a genuine question, I haven't done enough research to evaluate the truthfulness of it.
But, just because there are problems, that doesn't mean that the system doesn't work.
In the article that you posted, they mentioned 10's of millions of unnecessary antibiotics. The reason that antibiotics are prescribed for viral infections is twofold. And, it's primarily because people want them. If I take my child who has been sick for 1 week to the ER, spend 3 hours waiting in line for a 5-10 minute visit with an ER doc. I want to go home with a prescription in hand. If not, I'm going to be very angry. So, it's easier for the MD to prescribe an antibiotic than deal with the 5-10 minute conversation convincing the parents that it's only 2008 and we haven't found a cure for the common cold yet.
As for unnecessary medical procedures... That pretty much speaks to 95% of plastic surgery cases and 80% of dermatology practices.
Our society also has very high expectations of the medical community. We used to go to a shaman, priest or pastor when our family was dying and looked for answers or expected miracles. Now, we take then in a ambulance to the hospital and expect answers and miracles from our doctors and medical systems.
Doctors feel those expectations and generally work very hard in very difficult circumstances. They also are trying to make a decent living to pay for the 12-15 years of schooling they suffered through. So, the average MD will work 70-110 hours a week. When you work that much, you're bound to make mistakes.
There's no doubt about it, there are a lot of problems with the system, but that doesn't mean that we should throw the baby out with the bath water.
Tips to getting better health care:
#1 Bar none, go to the rich people's hospital. Go to the neighborhood with the most expensive homes, and find a doctor in that neighborhood. You get much better medical care in those areas because that's where the good doctors go to practice. After working in 35 different hospitals in 15 years, I settled on working at an upper class/upper middle class hospital in Silicon Valley. That was deliberate. I can give better care here than any where else I've ever worked.
You can dismiss it if you like, but what these numbers mean in more practical terms is this:
Over 5 years on treatment, it will prevent up to 1 person out of 10 from dying, having a stroke, or heart attack.
And there may be a negative study here or there, but there are many more positive studies. It's like flipping a coin 100 times in a row. There will be times when you get 70 heads, 30 tails, and times you will get 30 heads, and 70 tails. If you do it enough, it will average around 50% heads and tails. This is the "true" result or chance over time of getting heads or tails.
If you do a single study, you might get a negative result (no improvement), if you do another study you might get a really positive result (huge improvement). If you do it enough, the results with trend towards the "true" result... which for statins is that it saves a significant number of lives and prevents heart attacks and strokes in certain patients.
Your thinking is fundamentally flawed. 1.8 people out of 100 are prevented from dying, and not for free: there are side effects and financial costs. How many died in year six as opposed to year five is also unclear. We're talking about drugs they want to keep people on for the rest of their lives.
The cumulative arithmetic of how many escaped cardiovascular "events" and death cannot be computed clearly from the numbers presented, as you seem to allude.
You're first assertion was that these medications don't actually do anything. I simply am pointing out they do do something.
It comes at a cost of $$, possible side effects, sure. But if you are arguing that point, then you have to concede that if the price is low enough or the side effects are low enough, then it's worth it.
If it's not personally worth it to you to take the statin because you have side effects from it... that's fine. don't take it. But you can't use it as a blanket to say all medications don't do anything, just because you had a bad experience with one or don't agree with the cost/benefit analysis.
Personally, I'd say 1.8% over five years is nothing, and as I mentioned I've seen the abstract read closer to 0% or -X%. Think of it as 0.36% per year. Expect big lawsuits next decade about the side effects.
> you have to concede that if the price is low enough or the side effects are low enough, then it's worth it.
Not quite so simple, because there are lifestyle treatments that do work and are generally not pursued. The drug options are pursued at the opportunity cost of much more efficacious, much simpler, much less profitable options.
The numbers were statistically significant, which means the differences were not likely related to random chance.
The statin prevented 1079 people from having a stroke, dying, or having a heart attack. It helped 10% of the people in a non-trivial way in this study.
(and lifestyle changes are typically pursued alongside these medical treatments. Certainly in these studies, of course your individual doctor's mileage may vary.)
As for the 10 out of 100 total winners claim, it looks fudged up to me on quickly scanning the abstract. I'd have to use a calculator and read the study. That cute little bit about a compliance adjustment smells like fudge. And, as I've said, there are other studies with other conclusions.
2) You really don't seem to have a good grasp of what the statistics are telling you. Take the statins example. As others have tried to explain to you quite politely, the statistical improvement of statins vs placebo are both significant, and even impressive. Your response? 'Asshole'. Nice work.
It doesn't matter to you as an individual if you are prescribed heart medicine when you need it. However, it truly does save lives in society. How do you propose we scale back the system of medicine? Should doctors no longer prescribe statins?
Here's an example of the kind of thing that interests me: a recent meta-study of FDA trials of SSRIs (antidepressants) showed little to no benefit over placebo, below statistical significance in some important cases. So there's a fair chance that most people shouldn't get SSRIs because they just don't work.
"Drug–placebo differences in antidepressant efficacy increase as a function of baseline severity, but are relatively small even for severely depressed patients. The relationship between initial severity and antidepressant efficacy is attributable to decreased responsiveness to placebo among very severely depressed patients, rather than to increased responsiveness to medication."
Read it here.
http://medicine.plosjournals.org/perlserv/?request=get-docum...
Sure. Take Ambien, for example. The studies show it works! People who take it fall asleep a whole 15 minutes sooner than placebo! For thousands of dollars and unquantified long term consequences you can have something pathetically less effective than lifestyle changes or some cognitive therapy sessions, so ask your doctor about Ambien.
Same for the cholesterol statins. They work! They really do lower serum cholesterol, just as advertised. However, they have absolutely no affect on mortality rates in the typically prescribed case, and are implicated in serious neurological disease...
This kind of nonsense is pervasive in the medical industrial complex. Doctors, for the most part, dispense treatments pushed on them. But the stuff is largely a waste of money.
With a whole lot of these cancer therapies you statistically buy an extra year of life. But the person who took the therapies felt like shit for four years and blew all their savings. The person who just let it be died a year earlier but spent a lot more time feeling ok and saved a lot of money. You can just go on and on with stuff like this. The medical industrial complex is deeply dysfunctional, and at the end of the day there are way too many doctors and they do too much. This is why health care spending and number of doctors per capita is uncorrelated to lifespan and health across regions of the US.