News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:24AM (#22199322)
Say you have equity in a non public company, would you be okay if the government taxed your equity forcing you to take out a loan against it?
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by neilparikh on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:34AM (#22199373)
These 2 scenarios aren't equivalent. Land is an exclusionary good; you using it means I can't. Equity is non-exclusionary. Additionally, the city has to provide services to owners of land, which requires money. The government has no such obligation to owners of equity.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @08:18AM (#22201401)
Yes, land is exclusionary but there is plenty of it in the US. People in California just don’t want to live there.

The government also has to fund services to everyone who works there whether or not they own land. Do devices cost more to home owners based on the value of their land?

I thought the purpose of tax was to fund the government. Not to take stuff that other people wanted.....

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:39AM (#22201970)
I thought the purpose of tax was to fund the government. Not to take stuff that other people wanted.....

Property taxes are among the most economically efficient taxes that exist. They are an excellent way to fund the government.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:48AM (#22202045)
How are they "economically efficient"? It doesn't cost anymore to serve someone in a million dollar home than a $200K home. Besides that you get into situations where richer neigborhood have better services, better funded school systems, etc.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:20AM (#22202341)
Because they don't discourage otherwise positive economic activity.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:52AM (#22202619)
Do you feel the same way about the government taking private property via eminent domain to build a Walmart?
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:54AM (#22202638)
No.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:00AM (#22202684)
What's the difference? Either way you're taking property for "positive economic activity". A Walmart can bring more jobs than a group of houses....
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by tptacek on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:18AM (#22202827)
One obvious difference is that property taxes are applied uniformly and predictably --- a whole industry exists to plan around them --- and eminent domain is not, so widespread application of ED would create uncertainty that would discourage positive activity.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:40AM (#22203053)
What’s “predictable” about having to pay taxes on a property that you don’t know how much will appreciate? Someone who bought a house 30 years ago while they were working, paid it off and had enough in savings to pay their bills but not pay taxes on a house that went up 10x the rate of inflation couldn’t predict their tax bill.

What happens when they can’t pay their taxes? The government takes it.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by tptacek on Friday January 31, 2020 @01:05PM (#22203847)
This is an unserious argument. ED and property taxes aren't comparably unpredictable. An obvious illustration of this would be the fact that most places in the US don't have California's cap, and people manage tax planning just fine. If your real argument is, essentially, "taxation is theft", that's a coherent position, but since most people don't agree with the premise, you're not left with much to contribute to this particular discussion.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:35PM (#22204795)
No, I’m not saying that “taxation” is theft, but the undercurrent of raising property taxes on people who have been living in their houses for years is that the land could be better use by “more productive” tech bro’s than old people and if you raise the taxes enough, they would be forced to move.

Those same tech bro’s would hate it if they were taxed on unrealized, illiquid wealth.

But, yes there are plenty of jurisdictions that give property tax breaks to senior citizens.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by tptacek on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:30PM (#22205993)
This is how property taxes work pretty much everywhere else, dense and sparse, tight housing market and loose. It doesn't seem to be causing a crisis anywhere, unlike California's policy, which is implicated in an actual housing shortage.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:10PM (#22208372)
And since we do have 49 other states, if prices get to high - companies and people will move.

Problem solved.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:33AM (#22202977)
In addition to what tptacek said, taxes are paid with money which is an infinitely fungible commodity. Eminent domain confiscates a specific piece of property that cannot be precisely replaced.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:37AM (#22203019)
Money is a fungible commodity but a house isn’t. You can’t sell part of a house. If that’s where all of your wealth is.

You

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:56AM (#22203180)
You can’t sell part of a house.

Sure you can: https://point.com/how_it_works

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:03PM (#22203251)
Fair enough so we should also tax equity in private companies. That money could also be used for positive economic activity.....
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:07PM (#22203291)
I'm glad you've come around to my p.o.v. on property taxes!

The pros and cons of a mark to market capital gains tax are pretty far outside of the scope of this thread, so I will save my thoughts on them for another day.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:37PM (#22204814)
It’s the same concept. You want to tax illiquid unrealized wealth that may force people to sell the underlying illiquid asset to pay taxes.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @06:10PM (#22206926)
I already covered this way upthread. Property taxes aren't wealth taxes, they're consumption taxes.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:38AM (#22201962)
I don't understand why that is a relevant question.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:57AM (#22202122)
Because people are always willing to tax other people's wealth.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:10AM (#22202237)
Property taxes aren't wealth taxes, they're consumption taxes.

This is obvious when you consider the fact that a person who owns a piece of property outright pays the same property tax as someone who owns a similar piece of property but carries a mortgage.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:50AM (#22202603)
Does a person who owns a $1 million dollar home "consume" more resources than a person who owns a $200K home? What if the homes are the same but in different parts of the city?
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by amunicio on Friday January 31, 2020 @03:31PM (#22205352)
This is not a good argument. It would be the equivalent of me asking: Does the trash pickup service, repairing potholes or patrolling the street cost more if the home owner just moved in than if has own the house for 30 years?
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:30PM (#22205998)
Well, that does argue for my previous stated idea of charging every property owner the same fee for the same service.

Trash pickup is actually a great example. Where I live it’s not part of your property taxes. It’s a separate bill and everyone pays the same amount.

The city council can set budgets for the different departments and set taxes based on the budget. Neighborhoods already do something similar via homeowner’s association fees and condo fees.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:51AM (#22202611)
Yes.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:01AM (#22202691)
How so?
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:37AM (#22203023)
Some land is more valuable than other land. Living on top of more valuable land consumes a more valuable resource.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by hundt on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:48AM (#22203114)
You could make that argument about any property (e.g. art). I guess your definition of "consumption" is "having something someone else doesn't"? But that isn't what most people mean, I think.

Edit: I think a tax on imputed rent could maybe be considered a consumption tax, and it would indeed make sense for it to be higher or lower depending on the location of the property. But a tax on the value of the whole property is not, because it also captures the value of the property as an asset. So that's why I think your argument is too broad.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:01PM (#22203234)
Imputed rent is (roughly) proportional the the value of the property, So a tax on one is the same as a tax on the other.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by hundt on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:08PM (#22203301)
Yes, there's a consumption component and a non-consumption component. Of course when either component goes up the total goes up. But the tax is on the total value and therefore it's not a consumption tax.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:16PM (#22203398)
Let's say that imputed rent is, on average, 10% of the total value of the property.

That makes a 10% tax on imputed rent the exact same thing as a 1% tax on the value of the property.

So your point is really just an argument about the rate, not an argument about the fundamentals of what is being taxed.

Note that property taxes tend to be a fraction of sales taxes for exactly this reason.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by hundt on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:27PM (#22203510)
Yes, I understand this point but the ratio between rents and property values varies wildly. So yes you can compute an average ratio and say it is "equivalent" to a tax on imputed rent if you adjust by that ratio, just as you could average out the number of bathrooms in each house and say it is "equivalent" to a bathroom tax. But it's not a very compelling argument!
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:32PM (#22203560)
ratio between rents and property values varies wildly

Does it vary all that much within a specific property tax jurisdiction?

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by hundt on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:46PM (#22203696)
Sure! Here are some things that could cause the rent/value ratio to be significantly different for a single property:

- There is no usable building on your property.

- There are plans to build a highway through your neighborhood in five years.

- Amazon has announced plans to build an office in your neighborhood two years from now.

- There are harvestable (with further development) natural resources on your property.

Many of these have impacts on hypothetical future consumption, but hopefully you agree that a tax on anticipated future consumption indefinitely into the future is not a consumption tax.

I don't have data as to precisely how strong the correlation is, but I think it's pretty clear that it is not 1, and furthermore if we really wanted to tax imputed rent directly we could presumably do so (we'd have to guess what it is but the same challenge applies to valuations of properties that haven't sold recently). So I just don't think "consumption tax" is a good way to look at a tax that clearly captures, and is designed to capture, other things.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @06:16PM (#22206964)
I don't have data as to precisely how strong the correlation is

I'm actually pretty curious now, and might be go looking for data. It's surely not precisely 1, but I bet it's not all that far off. Especially if you limit the sample to residences.

Your list of outliers is a good one (I particularly like the natural resources one), but I think they're probably mostly exceptions to the rule.

In the end though sure, property taxes aren't precisely consumption taxes. But they clearly aren't wealth taxes either. They're something in between and, I think, much closer to consumption that wealth.

I've really enjoyed thinking about the points you brought up. Thank you for doing that.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by hundt on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:13PM (#22208386)
Thanks, I enjoyed the exchange as well. I am also curious about the correlation coefficient but could not find any details in the amount of time I had to put into it. I did get the feeling that there is substantial research in the area of what drives housing prices, though.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:01PM (#22203229)
The land isn’t more valuable because of some inherent virtue of the land.

It’s only more valuable because tech bro’s want it.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:05PM (#22203269)
You could say the same thing for almost all goods and services which are subject to consumption taxes.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:41PM (#22203640)
The cost of police, fire fighters, schools, roads, etc. don’t go up with the value of the home. There is no reason that you couldn’t charge a flat rate to every property owner - including businesses.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by likpok on Friday January 31, 2020 @06:41PM (#22207148)
The cost of all of these things do increase with the value of the home, because the labor required to do it gets more expensive. The individual house price doesn't contribute to this but overall housing costs do.

SF has had an explosion in property values and thus struggles to find teachers, firefighters and police officers at the salaries it's willing to pay.

Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @07:14PM (#22207390)
Again why should those taxes be based solely on housing instead of or in addition to other types of wealth?
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by harryh on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:43PM (#22203664)
We could do that, but then it would be more like a poll tax or a head tax instead of a consumption tax.
Re:California's housing bill SB 50 has died in the state Senate by scarface74 on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:40PM (#22204844)
How so, taxes are meant to fund the government and services they provide. Everyone who lives in a jurisdiction either consumes those government resources or we as a society have decided that it was in the common good to provide those services (ie education).