Not everything needs or ought to spark a new discussion. But I would up vote things I disagreed with if they were insightful. Retrodden political soundbites though? Nah
Re:Tell HN: Disagree ≠ Downvote
by JoeAltmaier on Monday February 14, 2011 @09:41PM
(#2219871)
I always do; I endorse that. Its hypocritical to reply if you don't think the comment is important.
What's so wrong with the idea of upvoting a post that you intend to rebut if it neatly articulates a reasonable position?