I think Tycho would agree. If the comment improved the discussion, it couldn't have been "bad for the world."
Re:Tell HN: Disagree ≠ Downvote
by JoeAltmaier on Monday February 14, 2011 @09:40PM
(#2219867)
Sometimes provoking a better comment makes a distressing comment useful; therefore upvoteable. Like I upvoted that distressing comment up there.
The voting mechanism means whatever the end user wants it to mean. I use a simple metric: did the comment improve, or detract from, the conversation?