News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by whoisjuan on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:31PM (#22196575)
What’s the point of this comment besides being inflammatory?

All those things are always discussed tirelessly in HN every time there’s something about Amazon. We get it. And it’s ok to bring them up here. But how about adding something useful to the discussion, instead of just making that statement and posting a bunch of links?

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by totalZero on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:41PM (#22196686)
Sadly, I found the parent comment more useful and less inflammatory than your complaint about its content.
Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by fludlight on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:41PM (#22196680)
Some people are jerks. Discussions about them always begin or end by stating that. It's a cost of being a jerk. Why should companies be treated differently?
Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by clSTophEjUdRanu on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:34PM (#22196601)
I thought it was insightful. 4 and 5 are what made me boycott Amazon and shop at, gasp, Wal-Mart. Amazon might be surging now but they are eroding consumer trust with this BS.
Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by Traster on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:50PM (#22196766)
I don't know about the original poster, but I think it's important when we talk about these massive 'success' stories that we're actually talking about the domination of capital holders over workers and the failure of regulators when it comes to technology companies.
Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by blibble on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:19PM (#22197567)
I note that the resume on your website states that you're currently employed at Amazon
Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by whoisjuan on Friday January 31, 2020 @06:19PM (#22206993)
I’m not. Used to. Could talk shit about Amazon for days, but that’s not the point of what I said.

Thanks for being super creepy, and digging through my profile. Unfortunately you couldn’t even get that right. And by the way, even if I still worked there I can’t see how that discredits my opinion.

But since you seem to going down that route, I can say confidently that I don’t like Amazon as an employer and many times I don’t like it when I interact with it as a customer. Mind blowing, right? Someone who can be critical and still tries to seek objective opinions.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by blibble on Monday February 03, 2020 @12:09AM (#22221574)
> Thanks for being super creepy, and digging through my profile.

no problem, next time there's a potential conflict of interest then state it in your post

> Unfortunately you couldn’t even get that right.

it's hardly my fault if your resume on your website is out of date

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by serf on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:37PM (#22196638)
>We get it.

Eh. Speak for yourself.

Either the vast market that they exploit is ignorant to their abuse of the world, or the vast market is knowingly participating in fairly a-moral behavior knowingly.

I prefer to think that people are generally good (moral) & naive, so i'll continue parroting the point everytime Amazon comes up, just on the off chance that i'll elucidate to someone Amazon's true nature that they may otherwise be unaware of.

Speaking of topics that are spoken of ceaselessly on HN : Amazon's success and profit. Where's your issue with that topic?

> What’s the point of this comment besides being inflammatory?

I think that's an absolutely atrocious response to anything human-rights related.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by pasabagi on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:47PM (#22196738)
I think moralizing about companies is stupid. If a company makes moral decisions, and as such, is less sucessful, they're probably going to get their lunch eaten by their less moral competition. The only antidote to this is laws that ensure some basic level of civility.

Capitalism is a nasty, amoral system by nature. Saying some companies are good and others are bad is just scapegoating.

If everybody boycotts amazon tomorrow, they'll be replaced by a company that does the same stuff - because amazon have proved that it works, and that it is profitable. Nothing but legistlation can stop that. Talking about how bad amazon is obcures this.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by luckylion on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:10PM (#22196979)
> The only antidote to this is laws that ensure some basic level of civility.

How do you figure those laws are created, if not by public pressure? And how would publish pressure be created if not by talking about the amoral behavior of companies?

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by pasabagi on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:16PM (#22197041)
In general, but not in specific. Saying that a specific practice should be illegal is productive. Saying that a particular company is bad is not - they'll simply say, 'we follow the law'. And they'll be right. Then the politicians will say, 'you can't ban Amazon'. And they'll also be right, because laws can't be targeted against specific groups.

If you target specific techniques and practices (for instance, child labour, historically) then the supporters and lobbyists have to actually justify the problematic stuff - they can't just hide behind the nebulous vagueness of all the things big companies do.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by totalZero on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:59PM (#22196887)
The ideology you are pushing will self-reinforce.

If everyone rewards companies for being nasty because that's somehow "smart" or "successful", then the nasty companies will be among the most successful ones.

If everyone boycotts companies that do unethical things, then those companies will be punished financially and ethical behavior will be economically incentivized.

Choose the world in which you want to live.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by pasabagi on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:13PM (#22197012)
The vast majority of customers buy products first on quality, second on price, then third on ethics. The third point is very tenuous, since it relies on specific, reliable information that the producer is highly incentivized to obfuscate.

I don't see how that could ever work. So, in my eyes, it's not choosing the world you want to live. It's engaging in some magical thinking to feel good about yourself. If you want to change the world, vote. Better still, organize. Take the time you would have spent researching the ethical status of one company or another and look into the history of campaigns to improve working conditions. Some campaigns have worked - but I have never heard of, and cannot imagine there are any, that were consumer boycotts.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by totalZero on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:08PM (#22197486)
1. You're making up vague statistics that I believe are false. If "the vast majority of customers" only "tenuous"-ly care about ethics, then why are major multinational corporations reacting to today's ethical concerns like climate change? Doesn't stand up to your own logic that companies do amoral things.

2. If you reward companies for being bad, then they will be bad. If you reward companies for selling blue items, they will sell more blue items. Your own logic about amorality dictates this. Why is it so hard to understand?

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by pasabagi on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:18AM (#22199773)
I guess I thought my 'vague statistics' were obvious and undeniable. If not, let's get concrete. Consider Union Carbide. They were responsible for the worst industrial disaster in history, with around 20,000 dead. They then went on to neither compensate the victims (including 40,000 permanent disabled) nor clean up the site.

This was widely publicized. According to your theory, such an extreme 'bad' act would have led to disaster for the company. In reality, it didn't even lead to rebranding. They were bought by Dow Chemicals - but that was because they had massive debts. I think they cannot have been related to the Bhopal disaster, since their compensation paid was very small.

One salient fact here is that moral hazard is not contagious. Many products are for other businesses, who aren't likely to pay a premium for ethical considerations. Another fact here is that even in the most famous and awful cases of bad companies, you're relying on the company's own branding to tell informed customers to stay away. Which is obviously extremely fragile - the company can rebrand, even if the customers are reliably informed (how many people on the street know about Bhopal? Is it present when they buy shrink wrap? Is it even possible to know that your shrink wrap was made using ethylene from union carbide?

All seems a bit absurd to me. Even before you get into the inherent asymetries of the idea (is Bill Gate's ethical opinion worth more than a billion poor people? As an ethical consumer, it is.)

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by HarryHirsch on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:58PM (#22196875)
Capitalism is a nasty, amoral system by nature. Saying some companies are good and others are bad is just scapegoating.

Actually, this isn't the case. Not too long ago, orphan drugs were actually reasonably priced. Cuprimine went up from 500 USD to 24000 USD for a 30-day supply when Valeant bought the original manufacturer, and Daraprim went up from 13.50 USD/dose to 750 USD/dose thanks to Shkreli: https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-senate-drug-price-stu...

Something changed, but I'm not sure what.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by refurb on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:15PM (#22197029)
Those drugs are going up in price so they reflect the prices of new orphan drug launches.

And they can do it since competition won’t bother to jump through FDA hoops.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by HarryHirsch on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:08PM (#22197492)
jump through FDA hoops

Not that again. Bioequivalence is important so that a patient can take Levothyroxin 75 μg from Ranbaxy one month and Levothyroxin 75 μg from Teva next month and notice no difference. Unfortunately, the market for orphan drugs is so small that it's impossible to recover the outlays.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by refurb on Thursday January 30, 2020 @10:01PM (#22198603)
Just as an aside, once you start on a thyroid medication, it’s recommended you stick with that manufacturer. Yes, they are bioequivalent, but to the FDA that means 80%-125% of the originator.

But yes, these markets where formally cheap drugs get 100x price increases are tiny markets where the outlay to get FDA approval is more than they’d make on it.

Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by point78 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:13PM (#22197008)
His comment is very useful. Amazon is a shit company that dodges taxes.
Re:Amazon soars after earnings beat by decebalus1 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:33PM (#22196593)
I'll add something useful! All of the above are cold, business sided stories. Let's get personal. If you're an employee and want to share your personal story, go check out https://sites.google.com/site/thefaceofamazon/home