News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monoliths Are the Future by jlmorton on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:10PM (#22196336)
That's a problem for the future data engineers to deal with. The data lake is an insurance policy so you only need to think about these problems if you later want the data. If you already know you want to analyze the data, then a data lake is not a good choice.

Yes, it makes life harder for the data engineers in the future, but it might turn out that analysts only ever need 5% of the data in the lake, and dealing with these schema changes for 5% of the data is easier than carefully planning a public schema for 100% of it.

It can be helpful to include some small amount of metadata in the export though, with things like the source system name, date & time, # of records, and a schema version. Schema version could easily be the latest migration revision, or something like that.

Re:Monoliths Are the Future by te_chris on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:48PM (#22196752)
The data lake is also a real, live GDPR PII time bomb if you worked out how to get the data in but not take it out
Re:Monoliths Are the Future by lolc on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:25PM (#22197616)
But if I haven't spent the effort to extract it, do I really own it? Let me argue that I don't have it because all my implemented queries turn up none of your data. You wouldn't tax me on gold that hasn't yet been extracted, would you? (End of joke.)
Re:Monoliths Are the Future by ska on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:48PM (#22197785)

  But if I haven't spent the effort to extract it, do I really own it? 
If you collected it, you are responsible for it.
Re:Monoliths Are the Future by yesbabyyes on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:05PM (#22197929)
What I think you'd typically do is put different data under different keys/paths, so that red is personally identifiable data, yellow contains pointers to such data, and green is just regular data. You could have a structure like s3://my-data-lake/{red|yellow|green}/{raw|intermediate}/year={year}/month={month}/day={day}/source={system}/dataset={table}

Then you just don't keep red data for longer than 30 days.