News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monoliths Are the Future by dcwca on Thursday January 30, 2020 @01:08PM (#22193634)
The author does not seem to understand when to correctly apply microservices. There are two basic use cases: 1) Different parts of your solution have different load patterns and it is economically beneficial to scale them at different rates and 2) Different teams need to be able to work & ship autonomously. It's not at all about technical merits or architectural beauty. It's about people and costs.
Re:Monoliths Are the Future by Glyptodon on Thursday January 30, 2020 @01:45PM (#22194053)
I kind of think the items (1) and (2) you list don't automatically mean micro-services, so much as they mean separation of concerns can be beneficial.

Isn't there room for a middle ground with modularity that can live in between a full blown monolith or a full blown microservices pattern, particularly for operations that are more medium scale?

Re:Monoliths Are the Future by unlinked_dll on Thursday January 30, 2020 @02:45PM (#22194707)
Yea just take the ideas that apply to your problem domain and implement them in a way that's sane. Design/architecture patterns are much more useful as templates to be specialized for your problem.

I really don't like the dogmatic view of architectures. Leaves no room for craftsmanship, and it's only really useful for creating code monkeys that have to follow a spec and need to be interchangeable cogs in the machine.

Re:Monoliths Are the Future by FlorianRappl on Thursday January 30, 2020 @02:39PM (#22194647)
Of course there is, was, and will be!

I think people sometimes forget that a healthy level of pragmatism is what keeps shipping. Just because someone said "microservices is the new all" you don't need to do it. Just because some said "monoliths are the future" it does not have to be true for you.

Take all these as case studies and solutions that apparently worked under specific conditions.

Re:Monoliths Are the Future by mikkergp on Thursday January 30, 2020 @02:13PM (#22194365)
megaservices
Re:Monoliths Are the Future by peteforde on Thursday January 30, 2020 @01:47PM (#22194067)
The author is a Kubernetes expert, so perhaps you are the student and not the master?

https://github.com/kelseyhightower/kubernetes-the-hard-way

Re:Monoliths Are the Future by bastardson on Thursday January 30, 2020 @02:25PM (#22194482)
A person’s perceived status shouldn’t win them an argument.
Re:Monoliths Are the Future by cc81 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:54PM (#22196174)
No, but the dude works at google and has written that and other books about Kubernetes so obviously he knows about scaling parts of a system and huge organizations working on software together.

That is not what he is commenting on here though. It is that microservice architecture is starting to become the default pattern on how to build applications for a lot of people. Instead it should be an exception when you reach those very specific problems that most people don't have.

Re:Monoliths Are the Future by peteforde on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:04AM (#22200177)
I didn't declare their argument won, lost or invalid. I did suggest that they consider the bona fides of the person whose opinion they were tossing off as uneducated.

Thanks for the downvote, though.

Re:Monoliths Are the Future by bastardson on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:44AM (#22202009)
> I did suggest that they consider the bona fides of the person whose opinion they were tossing off as uneducated.

It would be more constructive to give reasons why one argument is better than another though, rather than resorting to status, and you did not reference any of the commenter’s points.

> Thanks for the downvote, though.

I don’t have the karma required to give a downvote. I’m not sure who you should thank.

Re:Monoliths Are the Future by peteforde on Saturday February 01, 2020 @07:51AM (#22210234)
Honestly, you're missing or avoiding my point: I'm not deferring to the author because he's respected or has a popular blog.

I am suggesting that the OP has little business writing off a legitimate expert's opinion in a domain where they are highly qualified to comment. This isn't controversial.

If you had the karma to downvote, would you give a hard time to the OP who started with "The author does not seem to understand when to correctly apply microservices."?

Re:Monoliths Are the Future by dcwca on Saturday February 01, 2020 @12:56PM (#22211955)
Different dimensions of analysis, I guess. I’m not surprised the author isn’t talking about business drivers.