https://www.npr.org/2018/06/29/624467256/what-happened-with-...
I feel like siding with LinkedIn here would open up the web to extortion though, like troll companies that would send cease and desist letters to all scrapers (even search engines). I think it could be argued that letting one company scrape when another is denied is discrimination.
Then again, I don't know how conservative and republican-leaning courts decide corporate law. Maybe in this case since so much money is at stake, they might worry that banning scraping would infringe on something like free speech and ruffle the feathers of some of the wealthier contributors in their base. Especially on the media side since I imagine they use bots in one form or another to find newsworthy stories.
IANAL (obviously!), I just find it entertaining/dismaying to ponder these things in these times.
Gate the information behind a login then sue the scraper for violating TOS and not scraping itself, I can understand that.
> Sign up now for free access to this content > [...] > Email (NOTE: Free email domains not supported)
I think this sort of antinomy[1] sounds ironical especially in this thread. This is practically legal dependency injection pattern, when you call something free, then administer antinomies, catches-22, etc.
No ultimate decision was ever made, and no, this doesn't make web scraping 100% legal. Wake me up when there's a new announcement because anyone interested in this already know this old news.