News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The greatest migration: the history and mystery of Polyne... by jandrese on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:03PM (#22174581)
I've wondered if the geography of Polynesia didn't help in this regard. The area is a series of small islands out in a big ocean. People who wanted to move between the islands would gain a lot of experience in sea navigation in whatever their ships of the day were. Enough experience plus the human desire to explore means longer trips could mostly be a factor in how much food and fresh water you can pack with you.

By comparison their contemporaries had the luxury of being on the same landmass so they could stick to coastal waters and inland seas for the entire journey. They were not forced to learn the harsh lessens of the open oceans until much later so they have this mindset that open ocean sailing is a monumental feat that requires advanced technology.

As for why it was lost. The article speculates that it was climate change, but I think the lack of a system of writing is probably even more to blame. Some disaster kills off the school of deep ocean navigation and the skills are lost as the old sailors die off.

Re:The greatest migration: the history and mystery of Polyne... by JusticeJuice on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:34PM (#22176278)
>As for why it was lost. The article speculates that it was climate change, but I think the lack of a system of writing is probably even more to blame. Some disaster kills off the school of deep ocean navigation and the skills are lost as the old sailors die off.

I think it's a bit more complicated than that. When James Cook came through Polynesia, he brought syphilis which ravaged the populations of Tahiti, Hawaii, and others - weakening oral tradition of passing down information. Also, when europeans first came, they were overall very un-interested in preserving any oral history, and mostly just colonised and fucked over the local populations - playing out the classic tropes of colonisation.

Re:The greatest migration: the history and mystery of Polyne... by jandrese on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:00AM (#22181929)
European colonialists are definitely a type of disaster.
Re:The greatest migration: the history and mystery of Polyne... by ip26 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:36AM (#22182434)
Polynesia also has helpful ocean currents all over the place, which probably made propulsion easier & trip time faster, with the bonus of allowing smaller simpler craft.

My layman's understanding of European sailing history is full of oars, tacking, doldrums, rations, and complex multi-sail designs. All things you'd never have to contend with if there was always a powerful current headed to your destination.