News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by Camas on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:17PM (#22165825)
>Scotland [...] has a goal to source the equivalent of 100% of its electricity demand from renewable energy sources by the end of this year.

What does 'equivalent' mean in this sentence?

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by est31 on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:21PM (#22165853)
Scotland does not have an independent grid. There is an EU wide market to trade electric energy between countries. Some days they export elecric energy, other days they import it. Even if 100% of their local production is renewable, the energy they import is probably (partly) not. So I guess the 'equivalent' means that summed up over the entire year, they export at least the same amount of energy that they import.

You can check this site for the present state (it doesn't show scotland though): https://www.electricitymap.org/

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by gruez on Monday January 27, 2020 @10:32PM (#22166186)
>So I guess the 'equivalent' means that summed up over the entire year, they export at least the same amount of energy that they import.

This bit is important, because it's possible to be "100% renewable", yet at the same time spew massive amounts of carbon.

https://energy.stanford.edu/news/100-renewables-doesn-t-equa...

[dead]
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by thawaway1837 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:29AM (#22166952)
Scotland is hosting a climate summit, and chooses to market a climate achievement.

Yet you think this is all about virtue signalling to Westminster.

Your comment says a lot more about how England still sees itself at the centre of the world than about the (very real) glass of Holyrood and the SNP.

[dead]
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by arethuza on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:01AM (#22167671)
A number of commentators have pointed out that the 7% deficit figure doesn't make an awful lot of sense as it ignores a lot of factors regarding the structure of the UK economy that wouldn't necessarily be in place for an independent Scotland - so comparing the GERS 7% figure with a 3% figure for an actual independent country in the EU isn't comparing like with like. Makes good headlines though.

https://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2019/08/21/the-gers-data...

Edit: Article from the same source about GERS:

https://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2019/08/21/whatever-gers...

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by arethuza on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:14AM (#22168632)
And another:

https://weegingerdug.wordpress.com/2019/08/04/what-the-gers-...

Edit: Funny how the "deficit" only appeared at the time independence was first discussed as a real possibility:

https://wingsoverscotland.com/the-inverse-miracle/

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by woolly on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:27AM (#22167190)
To your last point: have Spain changed their position since they said they would not veto a Scottish application to rejoin [1]? I haven’t seen anything to suggest they have.

1. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/apr/02/spain-drops...

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by uncle_j on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:39AM (#22167232)
The article is over 2 years old and Alfonso Dastis isn't the current foreign minister.

In any event Scottish Independence isn't going to happen anytime soon with Boris Johnson shutting down any possibility of an Indy Ref 2 last week.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by woolly on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:59AM (#22167346)
So how then do you know that Spain will veto a Scottish application to rejoin? Have Spain produced a more up to date statement changing their position? If not, then are you not just spreading FUD?

edit: Also, Johnson shutting down the possibility of a second independence referendum is not the be all and end all: the Scottish government could pass legislation for one without a section 30, which would likely be challenged in court by the UK government. If the supreme court upholds the right for Scots to vote in a referendum, then it goes ahead.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by uncle_j on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:56AM (#22167653)
> So how then do you know that Spain will veto a Scottish application to rejoin?

It is what I suspect after living in Spain as an Expat near Gibraltar for 3-4 years. I wasn't aware the official position has changed, however the Spanish Politics is all over the place especially after Vox (a Nationalist / Anti-Immigration party) did quite well in Andalusia.

> Have Spain produced a more up to date statement changing their position?

I think it is irrelevant and I qualified why in my previous post.

> If not, then are you not just spreading FUD?

It is simply a political opinion based on what I have observed after previously living there.

> edit: Also, Johnson shutting down the possibility of a second independence referendum is not the be all and end all: the Scottish government could pass legislation for one without a section 30, which would likely be challenged in court by the UK government. If the supreme court upholds the right for Scots to vote in a referendum, then it goes ahead.

Boris Johnson is going curtain the Supreme Courts interference with how the Commons work so I wouldn't count on that. If one is to believe David Starkey (who is a historian) he believes that the Supreme court shouldn't exist and is something invented by Tony Blair. Dominic Cummings is doing a shake up of the Civil Service. So I wouldn't count on any of that being relevant for too much longer.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by matthewmacleod on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:07AM (#22167705)
I would stress that this is not really an appropriate venue for this sort of political argument – it's fine to talk about constitutional or political matters where the intersect with the story in question, but a shallow "lol those guys are so dumb" is probably not that much of a useful contribution at this point.
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by toomuchtodo on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:35PM (#22165936)
Might change with Brexit (re independent grid).
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by duxup on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:47PM (#22165990)
Is that likely?

Hard to imagine anyone wants to deal with that regardless of how they feel about Brexit.

Plenty of independent nation's share grids.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by jussij on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:24PM (#22166437)
Since we are talking hypotheticals, if those pushing for Scottish independence get their way, sometime in the future Scotland may find itself out of the UK and back in the EU.
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by Rexxar on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:47PM (#22165986)
They have nothing to win to do this.
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by toomuchtodo on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:48PM (#22165992)
I’m not arguing the rationality, only the possible outcome.

Texas has its own grid (ERCOT) because Texas. Humans are quirky.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by tito on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:22PM (#22165855)
It's the difference between using and selling to another country.

For example, let's say my energy demand for 1 year is 1 GW. I generate that 1 GW using solar. But I sell 50% of it to a neighbor. Inside my house, I use gas for that missing 50%. Overall, I've "generated 100%" of my needs from renewables. I (Scotland) sell clean energy to my neighbor (Europe).

I skimmed this article for inspiration: http://euanmearns.com/scotlands-wind-exports-to-england-and-...

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by NeedMoreTea on Monday January 27, 2020 @10:10PM (#22166089)
Pretty sure the UK National Grid does not have interconnects and pricing between Scotland and England in the same way as between UK and interconnect partners in the EU. It's part of the same grid. Scotland has no choice but that some of it be fossil unless and until England and Wales are fully renewable also. Northern Ireland and Orkney do have interconnects.

So they can monitor total renewable generation, and total consumption, but can't have influence on what the shortfall is made up by. I've no doubt the grid will move toward more locality as it redesigns for a smart grid suitable for 100% renewables, and Scottish independence might provoke formal interconnecting.

For now they are both in the same 'house'.

Edit: I find myself newly suspicious of that site's agenda as he links to Watts Up With That, a notorious and extreme denialist site in his blog role. His phrasing may have been carefully chosen to downplay and minimise the achievement. He seems to have a fair time in the oil industry from his about page.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by makomk on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:30AM (#22167804)
I don't think it's just a question of Scotland not having a choice about where the shortfall is made up by, but of the shortfall having to be made up using fossil fuels.

For context, because Scotland is so big and empty, a disproportionate chunk of UK wind power is based there compared to their population - so much so that if I remember correctly their wind power has to curtail sometimes due to interconnect limits with the rest of the UK. It's kind of hard to get day-by-day or hour-by-hour figures for Scotland alone, but Scottish nuclear + renewables in the entire UK dropped well below Scotland's peak demand a good few times just in the last two months. That shortfall has to be made up using fossil fuels, there's no alternative - and a good chunk of that is going to be Scottish fossil fuel plants due to interconnect limits.

The Scottish government is simply using the fact that a disprortionate amount of UK wind power ended up there to spin themselves as less dependent on fossil electricity than they are. You can't measure progress towards an 100% grid using net figures like this because the last bit of demand is so much harder to satisfy renewably than the first, and countries with the ability to play silly tricks like this with net power can skip the hard part and pretend they've solved the problem. If/when renewable generation in England and Wales increases it might well even roll this figure back as less electricity is imported during peak wind generation, despite the fact that both Scotland and the rest of the UK would be getting more of their actual electricity from renewable sources.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:23AM (#22169080)
It's the Orkney interconnect that's at capacity. They really need an extra one.

Sure it's a lot of PR, but it's not just empty PR with a grid that's controlled mainland wide, and chooses sources minute to minute depending on availability, demand and price it's the best they can do. Scotland can, and does, encourage a much healthier approach to the adoption of renewables than Westminster. With more powers to the regions outside London, including Holyrood, so much more could, and would be done.

You can make the same criticism for every use of home solar panels, of green suppliers, of the whole transition to sustainable, and even of the entire markets for gas and electric considering we can't segregate individual electrons and atoms.

It's kind of hard to get Scotland figures alone because there is no separate Scottish grid, nor interconnects as such, just the mainland National Grid encompassing the three mainland countries. It's accounting, but it's not silly, it's the market we're all forced to participate in. We could have more precise regional figures with regional grids with interconnects between. We're not really large enough to need or justify that. Scottish independence, if it ever comes, might well see a Scottish grid as separate entity.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by makomk on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:56AM (#22170494)
You're right that the same criticism could and perhaps sometimes should be aimed at "net zero" homes with solar. Arguably solar is even worse than wind in the UK, because we're so far north that it has an awful capacity factor and it reliably drops off when power is needed the most. Ecohomes and net-zero homes have extra insulation that does provide a benefit in winter, but home solar alone is dubious. (The UK government also basically killed off subsidies for it.) It's a little more useful in countries closer to the equator with better capacity factors and summer aircon rather than winter heating, since output is reasonably closely correlated to demand then, but still won't get us to actual zero even there.
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:55PM (#22173934)
No it's not dubious at all. It's hilariously beneficial considering how far north we are, where I honestly thought it would be very borderline, and probably not worth it at all.

We just about eliminated the electricity component of the typical UK supply of electricity and gas for heating. That's not net zero, or creative accounting, that's actually eliminate use of grid electric for nine or ten months, with a little use in winter. That only because of switching water heating to the panels, that was previously on gas. We're in N Cumbria.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by fyfy18 on Monday January 27, 2020 @10:21PM (#22166139)
This is about electricity, not energy, demand though, so it's more like your neighbour runs a coal fired power plant that you import 50% of your electricity from.

If you look at energy consumption as a whole it's not that great though, in 2017 Scotland consumed 149 GWH, of which 24 GWH was electricity.

I don't think any other European countries are really doing any better though, Germany which is often touted as the leader in renewables, generates most of its electricity from fossil fuels (and most of that from coal and peat). This is why we need countries (and people) to take these climate goals seriously - even if you don't accept climate change, it's easy to see that generating 100% of your own energy from renewables will be more economically stable and sustainable in the long term.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by cygx on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:26AM (#22168372)
Germany [...] generates most of its electricity from fossil fuels (and most of that from coal and peat)

Germany doesn't use peat for energy production. We did run two plants in the past, but they closed in 1965 and 1974

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by Mirioron on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:50PM (#22166560)
>it's easy to see that generating 100% of your own energy from renewables will be more economically stable and sustainable in the long term.

Is it though? Europe doesn't seem like a particularly good spot spot for renewable energy. We've already put hydro pretty much everywhere we can, but the rest needs to be covered by pretty subpar options. Europe is further north than the US, which makes solar much less appropriate of a choice. Europe is also a lot smaller with more population density and that makes wind more difficult to do.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by fyfy18 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:52AM (#22167303)
My comment was meant as opposed to relying on fossil fuels imported from other nations; Europe as a whole imports 87% of it's oil [0], most of which comes from Russia [1]. If the same capital would be spent on renewable domestic energy generation, it would lead to a more stable economy in the long term, as well the benefits of local jobs and not funding countries with questionable regimes (where a lot of oil comes from).

It's a completely different story for the US. As I understand, domestic reserves are expected to last until the mid 2030s, but that assumes no new reserves will be discovered. Unfortunately as a lot of our technology comes from the US, it means the world as a whole is pretty dependent on the US energy economy and their political decisions regarding sustainability.

[0] https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...

[1] https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by Mirioron on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:23AM (#22169580)
>My comment was meant as opposed to relying on fossil fuels imported from other nations; Europe as a whole imports 87% of it's oil [0], most of which comes from Russia [1].

I misunderstood you then, because I wholeheartedly agree with this. This is also workable politically because of the energy independence plans of the EU. The discussions around Nord Stream 2 are an example of this.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:53AM (#22166794)
This is based on what?

Europe has some of the best spots on the planet for wind generation. Winds are in many places, a near constant companion, and usually within the range that turbines prefer. Any one of Britain, Ireland and the Nordics could supply a huge proportion of Europe's power needs with fully developed offshore wind. With a slim chance of ever being becalmed. Together I wouldn't be at all surprised to find generation capacity above European needs. There's plenty of suitable onshore sites too, and plenty of other European countries not yet mentioned.

Solar is never going to generate as much per panel in Scotland and UK as in California or Saudi, but it's good enough to pay well economically and in terms of emissions and overall impact too. Why wouldn't we use it in the mix? There's plenty of roof space doing nothing else.

New hydro has less scope, but there are suitable sites, and a large selection of locations suitable for pumped storage -- some of them part prepared by already having a lake in a disused quarry!

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by fyfy18 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:55AM (#22167323)
> Solar is never going to generate as much per panel in Scotland and UK as in California or Saudi, but it's good enough to pay well economically and in terms of emissions and overall impact too. Why wouldn't we use it in the mix? There's plenty of roof space doing nothing else.

Regarding this I live at 54N, and here installing roof top solar will pay for itself in less than 10 years. That's excluding government grants, and any electricity you are paid for exporting, so in reality it could be as little as 5. After that you have free energy for the life of the system - the inverter will last 15-25 years, solar panels will last the life of the building, but will produce less power over time.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by Mirioron on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:14AM (#22169519)
>Europe has some of the best spots on the planet for wind generation. Winds are in many places, a near constant companion, and usually within the range that turbines prefer.

And how much area does that require? Sure, the countries with a long coast might be able to do it, but others might not be able to as easily. Even if they can do it, electricity and land prices would be more expensive there than elsewhere. I'm not sure how this would work politically, because business would probably just move to the other parts of the EU.

>the Nordics could supply a huge proportion of Europe's power needs with fully developed offshore wind.

The further you have to transport electricity the less efficient it becomes. And when you say "Nordics" here are you talking about just Denmark or do you include Sweden too? Because remember, Norway is not in the EU.

This kind of an energy solution is likely unthinkable politically as well. It would render some nation states vulnerable to others.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:08AM (#22170638)
Well the regions with the most wind tend to concentrate in Western Europe, conveniently with lots of Atlantic, North Sea, and to a somewhat lesser extent Baltic coasts. Summer winds down in N Africa.

I include Norway as we're talking about Europe, and there are two interconnects coming with the UK -- one in progress, one planned, and other EU-Norway links coming. UK has about 5 others in progress to Netherlands, Ireland and elsewhere. There's loads of new interconnects in the pipeline within the EU and to surrounding. I've even seen Iceland in one interconnect proposal, which was somewhat surprising. Proposed interconnects to N Africa less so. There's lots of suitable onshore sites too, mainly in spots where other uses of the land are limited.

Politically not at all unthinkable though -- think of most nation's reliance on imported coal, oil, and gas, much of it for generation. That's more risky. Two way interconnect agreements are much less risk by comparison to import only, often from volatile oil and gas states. Reduced reliance on imported fossil energy is one of the big reasons it's heading that way and started in the first place.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by cygx on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:36AM (#22169698)
Because remember, Norway is not in the EU.

So? The grids of the Nordic countries are already interconnected. There's also a 700 MW cable connecting Norway to the Netherlands, and plans for connections to Germany and the UK.

Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by eigenvector on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:26PM (#22165876)
The total energy generated from renewable sources over some time period (let's say a calendar year to account for seasonal variance) equals the total energy consumed in the same period. However, renewable generation does not equal total consumption instantaneously at every moment in that period.
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by Qworg on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:32PM (#22165916)
Sadly, the Orkneys could provide even more renewables if Scotland would build a larger export cable. Instead, the islands are forced to build hydrogen plants and turn off wind generators. Last I checked, they were at 108% renewable.
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by NeedMoreTea on Monday January 27, 2020 @10:11PM (#22166097)
It does mean some interesting work is being done using hydrogen as storage, and for the ferries (not sure how far along the hydrogen ferries are).
Re:Scotland to use 100% renewables on time to host 2020 clim... by brailsafe on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:21PM (#22165849)
My thought was that it was a way of saying net zero use of renewables as in io. But I don't know if that makes any sense.