News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Please Review FavoriteThing.Me by rlmw on Monday February 14, 2011 @07:10AM (#2216452)
Minor issue - your front page has a block of text thats an image. As a result at least three kittens have died.

Had a quick look around. The idea seems nice, but I think stuff like this has to look more 'fun' in order to succeed. Its a really weird thing to describe, and I'm not great at articulating emotions about technology - but your site doesn't seem 'fun'. Perhaps this is just an aesthetic thing that you can solve quite easily though.

Another thing is that this seems like the kind of project that you could probably get a big viral bump from facebook or twitter. For example '@foo things @bar is sexy' and some kind of wall post spamming probably generates traffic. When you come to monetize, attaching your data to people's logins might be worth more money than your data alone.

Re:Ask HN: Please Review FavoriteThing.Me by ecto on Monday February 14, 2011 @08:29AM (#2216651)
Can here to say all 3 of these.

The first feeling I got from the design is that the site was kind of shady. I felt hard-pressed to put a password in the box.

The idea is really cool though. You'd need to integrate some kind of social login for it to get any traction I think.

Re:Ask HN: Please Review FavoriteThing.Me by dshipper on Monday February 14, 2011 @01:15PM (#2217833)
Thanks we're definitely going to work on that. We appreciate the feedback!
Re:Ask HN: Please Review FavoriteThing.Me by ajaymehta on Monday February 14, 2011 @10:06AM (#2216962)
I totally get what you mean. Not being web designers, it's pretty hard for us to feel out what works and what doesn't -- we kind of just subscribe to the trial-and-error method.

If you think of anything we can do to make it look more "fun" we're completely open!