News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leaked documents expose Avast antivirus subsidiary sellin... by gnicholas on Monday January 27, 2020 @03:05PM (#22163256)
Thanks for posting this. I have had similarly odd experiences recently with the Firefox addon store, which my startup has been in since 2013. All of a sudden we got yanked, among other things because we modify third party libraries. Apparently we would have been fine if we did exactly the same thing but wrote the code ourselves, but since we used a library, and then modified it, we were in violation. To be clear, we provide all our source code in the review process, so it is 100% clear what we are doing. And we don't do anything that is remotely privacy- or security-compromising, which is very clear from the code.

We tried to understand this bizarre no-modifying-third-party-libraries policy and see how we could fix it, but they stopped responding and eventually even deleted our extension from the browsers where our users had previously installed it. (Even Apple doesn't do this when it yanks apps — only rarely if there is proven bad behavior will the pull an already-installed/paid-for app from a device.)

I happen to know a couple very high-up people at Mozilla, and one of them was able to flag our mistreatment, and the reviewers now seem to be walking back the previously-described global ban on modifying third-party libraries, but we're still not back in the addon store (it's been months).

The (alleged?) policy makes no sense to me, and I also don't understand why Mozilla is now blocking users from installing any addon that hasn't been blessed by Mozilla. I understand that they want to vet addons that are listed in their store, but they've assured me that users can't even install off our website unless Mozilla signs off. That seems very un-Mozilla-ish to me. What happened to the open web?

For the record, I used to love Mozilla/Firefox, and have used their browsers for decades. I now use Brave, both because of experiences like this one, and because it's much faster on my Mac.

Re:Leaked documents expose Avast antivirus subsidiary sellin... by the8472 on Monday January 27, 2020 @06:06PM (#22164798)
> The (alleged?) policy makes no sense to me

The most charitable explanation I can come up with is that they want to avoid confusion attacks on their reviewers. But then again they already have a list of hashes for trusted libs, so clearly they could just diff the modified library against the canonical version when a hash doesn't match.

> but they've assured me that users can't even install off our website unless Mozilla signs off. That seems very un-Mozilla-ish to me. What happened to the open web?

I have clashed with their addons staff over similar issues. Their argument is basically security absolutism, motivated by (some) users easily being tricked. Any inch of rope you give the user they will use to hang themselves. So any security-related decisions they make are based on this dumbest possible user. Additionally they consider it a reputational issue, if an extension screws up firefox then firefox is blamed, or so they say.

Firefox stable basically means nannying. If you want more control you're supposed to use developer edition or (on linux) the distribution builds. They don't say it quite that directly, but that's what their answers boil down to.

Re:Leaked documents expose Avast antivirus subsidiary sellin... by gnicholas on Monday January 27, 2020 @06:15PM (#22164885)
> Their argument is basically security absolutism, motivated by (some) users easily being tricked.

Honestly, most of the people I know who use FF these days are pretty tech-savvy. This wasn't always the case — my mom used to use Firefox. But Chrome/Safari/Edge are the default browsers these days, and they're pretty good. The only people installing other browsers are either pretty savvy, or being helped out by people who are savvy.

I realize that Mozilla perhaps yearns of the days when they had much larger market share (and therefore many more easily-tricked users). But those days seem to have passed.

Likewise, they may be trying to position themselves to become the go-to browser for the unwise masses. And perhaps someday they will retake that crown. But in the meantime, these nanny-state restrictions piss of their developer-heavy base.

Re:Leaked documents expose Avast antivirus subsidiary sellin... by BlueTemplar on Monday January 27, 2020 @08:43PM (#22165684)
And yet another example why "OS" owners (since it pretty much boils down to this) should NOT be allowed to own an "app store" !