News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nokia admits it rejected Android; eyes "billions" in reve... by ZeroGravitas on Monday February 14, 2011 @05:31AM (#2216233)
I think the Nokia decision was the right one for Nokia, but the given reasons are BS.

Basically Nokia could have ended the smartphone war by joining with Android. But ironically, that makes them more valuable to Microsoft. This is just the same as Microsoft paying people to build apps for WP7, paying Verizon to use Bing, or paying devs not to release games on PS3 but on a massive, multi-billion dollar scale. It's a bit tragic when the greatest value your company can offer is to be paid to not join the dominant ecosystem in exchange for a cut of a desperate monopolist's war chest, but that's why you need to bring outsiders with no emotional attachment to your products in to do it.

So basically he wanted to "create a challenger" because Microsoft would pay them handsomely to do so. And if it doesn't work out, it's not like Android is going anywhere, so they've got a Plan B. (Though to be honest I think they're currently splitting the company into two pieces, the bit that will wring any remaining revenue from Symbian then close, and the bit that Microsoft will buy once they've sacked anyone Microsoft doesn't need. Microsoft will then try the PlaysForSure -> Zune thing again.)

Re:Nokia admits it rejected Android; eyes "billions" in reve... by chalst on Monday February 14, 2011 @06:07AM (#2216313)
that makes them more valuable to Microsoft ... because Microsoft would pay them handsomely to do so

So why did Nokia not get a better deal from Microsoft? The drop in Nokia's shares wasn't because they went for WP7, it's because they didn't get any kind of exclusivity deal.

Re:Nokia admits it rejected Android; eyes "billions" in reve... by rst on Monday February 14, 2011 @08:56AM (#2216736)
I'm not really sure we know what kind of deal they got; a lot depends on how those "billions of dollars" of payments are structured.

For instance, the maps licensing deal: does this mean that Nokia will be getting royalties (for the mapping software) on sales of other manufacturers' handsets? If so, they haven't got an exclusive, but they do have a favored position.

EDIT: if it's just advertising services, on the other hand, which is all Elop explicitly mentioned, then this does look pretty raw.

Re:Nokia admits it rejected Android; eyes "billions" in reve... by chalst on Monday February 14, 2011 @09:52AM (#2216913)
About details: agreed. But you'd think Nokia would say something concrete about how great the deal is, given their shareholder's mood at the moment. What's the plan? Use the billions to make a surprise dividend?

Maps is the kind of thing analysts were looking at. But I understood the deal as saying that MS would have a special search interface for Nokia users that integrated with Maps, not that WP7 would syndicate the service. That would be in the category of "less that complete surrender over UI".

Re:Nokia admits it rejected Android; eyes "billions" in reve... by colinplamondon on Monday February 14, 2011 @09:42AM (#2216875)
Desperate monopolist? They have 5% market share on mobile.
Re:Nokia admits it rejected Android; eyes "billions" in reve... by sethg on Monday February 14, 2011 @09:46AM (#2216886)
They are a monopolist because most of the world depends on Windows and Office.

They are desperate because they know that in the long run, Windows and Office will be irrelevant.

Re:Nokia admits it rejected Android; eyes "billions" in reve... by grhino on Monday February 14, 2011 @09:48AM (#2216893)
Leveraging their market share on the desktop to grow their market share on mobile.
Re:Nokia admits it rejected Android; eyes "billions" in reve... by shareme on Monday February 14, 2011 @07:11AM (#2216455)
Gosh you mean all those lawsuits did not work?

Nokia has shown it was incapable of creating a challenger as it resorted to lawsuits rather than change. Without MS firing middle management will not happen with MS paying Nokia either. Its Siemens Handset biz replayed out again.