It should also be noted that the total atmosphere (dry + water) is about 3% water vapor by weight and H2O makes up the majority of the greenhouse effect.
CO2 isn't a problem because it's the biggest greenhouse gas, it's a problem because it's the one (the biggest anthroprogenic one) pushing us over the equilibrium where net warming is zero.
This is actually an incredibly important point, because higher temperatures mean more water vapor in the atmosphere. However, that also means more clouds, which counteracts warming to some degree.
The impact of clouds on climate change is one of the biggest difficulties in modeling climate change. The IPCC report goes into it a bit. My understanding is that computationally it's a bit like predicting the weather into the future - a lot of uncertainty due to the chaotic nature of the system.
For a long-term climate model, it might work to average out (over space and time) some critical phenomema and assume a steady function from e.g. average air temperature to ice cap size and cloud cover.
(source: wrote some homework-grade numerical simulations, physics major.)
Carbon is not 4% of the air, it's 0.04%, a thousand times less concentrated again. To get "1 litre of carbon solid"[1] out means sucking in and paying the cost of processing 2,500,000 litres of air.
[1] as if that means anything sensible here, lol.
The low concentration means CCS will be slow. However, we can’t drop CO2 to pre-industrial levels in a week, that would probably cause significant climate instability. The logical thing to do would be to drop the levels at around the same rate as we have increased them. That may be too slow to prevent significant climate change in the meantime. Perhaps the rate could be adapted to how bad things seem.
The NOAA has a station on Mauna Loa in Hawaii. It has been continuously collecting CO2 data since 1958 and CO2 has gone from just over 300ppm to the current 414ppm.
I think many of us just haven't internalized the percentages of gasses, and probably, like myself, often have it all backwards. An alien doing a fly-through of our solar system would describe our planet as a nitrogen atmosphere.
In descending order:
Groking that last value really helps frame the challenges that CCS has to deal with (and also gives one an appreciation of just how powerful of a greenhouse gas CO2 is).