> From a macro perspective, focussing on one over the other is misleading.
from a societal perspective, it's a tax "refund" for the wealthy to enable stock buybacks over dividends, since capital gains are taxed less, and can be tactically spread out by in time to minimize the effective rate. At the same time, a company's spending on stock buybacks are considered an expense (rather than a capital expenditure), therefore decreasing the tax bill on a company's balancesheet.
I think stock buybacks should cost the company the same as dividends - that is, they should be taxed at the same rate, and also not be considered an expense that they can offset taxes from.
Buyback volume is comparable to dividend volume [1]. Both return cash to investors. From a macro perspective, focussing on one over the other is misleading.
Buyback and dividend cash can be consumed or re-invested. Given corporate buybacks pale in comparison to broader funds flows, it looks like it's being reinvested.
Even if every investor selling into a buyback consumed the cash, those buybacks are largely being funded by debt. On the net, that translates to investors hopping up the capital structure. Not exiting the capital markets.
[1] https://www.yardeni.com/pub/buybackdiv.pdf