News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JetBrains to reimagine IntelliJ as text editor, add machi... by coldtea on Saturday January 25, 2020 @04:23AM (#22145531)
>1. I hate the idea of paying for the thing I write code in.

Do you hate the idea of being paid for the code you write? Or it's only other people's software that should be free?

>2. IDEs tend to be optimized for the write path, when it’s the read path that really matters.

Actually it's the exact opposite. Plain editors like vim are optimized for the write path -- they have all kinds of text manipulation options built in, and they're 99% about text manipulation. IDEs have code navigation options, source control integration, refactoring tools, even collaboration options in some cases, all of which are about the read path.

>3. Most of the people I admire at work and in open source don’t use an IDE.

Some of them use an Emacs so loaded that it's just a Greenspun-10th-rule-style re-implementation of an IDE. And tons of great developers use IDEs, from Notch to John Carmack, to Ken Beck. If you constrict the "people you admire" to old school UNIX neckbeards, then sure.

>4. Not being able to use my text editor I’m a terminal is just a nonstarter for me. It’s immensely convenience, and some workplaces can’t even handle local development because of monorepos.

Monorepos have nothing to do with local development or not. You can export a specific project out and work on it. Googlers use all kinds of IDEs, despite the monorepo.

Not being able to run in a terminal being a non-starter, is dubious, as 99% of the time a programmer doesn't need to work in a remote shell session, exception if they're a sys admin.

>5. IDEs rob you of the knowledge of the underlying tools, locking you into an ecosystem that you can’t take with you all the time.

Take with you were? You aren't going anywhere. You can always use an IDE whatever the circumstances. People use IDEs in games, data science, application programming, embedded development, aviation, web programming, etc. Not sure which realm would prohibit the use of an IDE.

>6. I’ve worked in plenty of places that didn’t have JB stuff available. Never worked at a place you couldn’t use vim or emacs.

There are tons of companies that mandate a specific corporate-decided development environment for all programmers, where you can't just "have vim or emacs".

There are no comments on this comment yet.