News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by Luyt on Sunday February 13, 2011 @06:53PM (#2214531)
The weather is not the same as climate. When climate changes (and it has always changed in the past) some places become hotter, others become colder. Some places will get more precipitation, other places will become dryer.

The ice core drillings in deep layers of ice are a great way to learn about the history of climate. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_core

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by TomOfTTB on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:03PM (#2214580)
I'm sorry and I mean this in the least insulting way I can manage but how on earth can you not see the contradiction there? You actually said...

The weather is not the same as climate. When climate changes (and it has always changed in the past) some places become hotter, others become colder.

And then one sentence later say...

The ice core drillings in deep layers of ice are a great way to learn about the history of climate

An Ice Core is a snapshot of conditions present in the area where the snow that makes it up froze. Weather readings from an Ice Core are only accurate to determine the weather in that one area not the overall climate.

I don't even care about the Global Warming angle (every HN thread I've ever seen on the topic just devolves into partisan bickering) but the fact that you can't see that contradiction is disturbing.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by moe on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:17PM (#2214627)
Why not read the wikipedia page he linked before attacking him like that?

  An ice core from the right site can be used to reconstruct an 
  uninterrupted and detailed climate record extending over 
  hundreds of thousands of years, providing information on
  a wide variety of aspects of climate at each point in time.
Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by TomOfTTB on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:54PM (#2214723)
How would that work? I mean, I'd like you to explain to me how an ice core from one specific location could give you an accurate reading on the global climate? And if it's really possible to determine global climate from one location than why do we have all these weather stations around the world?

The answer is "because it isn't possible". Ice cores can provide climate information such as soot in the atmosphere and CO2 levels but it can only give you information on the specific location it was taken from. Any information determined from that regarding the global climate is extrapolation.

The text you quote is describing an extrapolation as an absolute. Or in other words just because you read something on Wikipedia doesn't make it true.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by moe on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:03PM (#2214753)
I mean, I'd like you to explain to me how an ice core from one specific location could give you an accurate reading on the global climate?

  The properties of the ice and the recrystallized inclusions within the  
  ice can then be used to reconstruct a climatic record over the age range 
  of the core, normally through isotopic analysis.
Ice cores can provide climate information such as soot in the atmosphere and CO2 levels but it can only give you information on the specific location it was taken from.

  The variety of climatic proxies is greater than in any 
  other natural recorder of climate, such as tree rings or 
  sediment layers. These include (proxies for) temperature, 
  ocean volume, precipitation, chemistry and gas composition 
  of the lower atmosphere, volcanic eruptions, solar 
  variability, sea-surface productivity, desert extent and 
  forest fires.
Just because you read something on Wikipedia doesn't make it true.

See, I'm not a climate scientist. Neither do I believe everything I read on wikipedia. But the article has plenty links and references to suggest there are many institutions and universities involved with this kind of research.

Sure, it could all be one big conspiracy. But somehow I find it easier to believe that you're just too lazy to read.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by TomOfTTB on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:17PM (#2214783)
Either I'm too lazy to read or you're too dumb to realize what the word "extrapolate" means. Here's a quote for you...

In mathematics, extrapolation is the process of constructing new data points outside a discrete set of known data points.

http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/extrapolate

When you're taking other information and trying to combine it to reconstruct a climate history that's extrapolation. That means you don't have an actual record and you're making an educated guess as to how other factors might be combined to provide you that missing record.

And again you haven't answered my most basic question. If you could get an accurate reading on the global temperature from one location than why do we bother with all the weather stations?

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by moe on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:31PM (#2214826)
I have no idea what kind of axe you have to grind here, but of course it's extrapolation and approximation. What else do you expect, SD Cards with digital weather records from 10k years ago buried into the ground?

The point is that many people who are much more familiar with the subject than us two seem to agree that the extrapolation is accurate enough to draw certain conclusions from.

If you aren't too busy with your ad hominem attacks then it would be nice if you could make a factual point beyond "Wikipedia is wrong" and "The climate research community is wrong".

What exactly are they doing wrong?

If you could get an accurate reading on the global temperature from one location than why do we bother with all the weather stations?

Well, I think we do the ice thing to learn about the time before we had weather stations.

Also all it takes is a look at the TOC of that wikipedia page to notice they're using not one but dozens of core sites on multiple continents.

I'm almost sure they're not extrapolating from just a single block of ice, as you're trying to suggest here...

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by nika on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:19PM (#2214790)
"See, I'm not a climate scientist. Neither do I believe everything I read on wikipedia. But the article has plenty links and references to suggest there are many institutions and universities involved with this kind of research. Sure, it could all be one big conspiracy. But somehow I find it easier to believe that you're just too lazy to read."

Or maybe he raised a point that is eluding you because you don't understand the science. His claim is not that there are no institutions looking at ice cores, and the text you quoted actually lends support to his argument.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by moe on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:34PM (#2214837)
He's throwing around broad claims (wikipedia is wrong, climate research is wrong) and making ad hominem attacks without providing a factual point of his own.

I don't claim to understand the science in depth. But neither do I see why I should take his word over what appears to be the current consensus in scientific climate research.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by nika on Monday February 14, 2011 @11:11PM (#2220111)
You are the one calling him names, and you are the one engaging in ad hominem, and you are not even being honest about what he said. (eg: he never said "climate research is wrong")

In fact, you jumped in here, depsite knowing nothing about the science, and have made quite an ass out of yourself.

But of course, the reasonable people who have been patient with your are down voted and you are upvoted.

Because you support global warming.

This site is a hive mind, full of unthinking idiots and thus not worth wasting time on.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by nika on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:44PM (#2214869)
Since you seem to be online, let me walk you thru an example.

What do you believe is the "current consensus in scientific climate research" on whether glaciers are shrinking or growing? On the balance, are they receding?

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by zeteo on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:05PM (#2214589)
"...scientists have been warning for at least two decades that global warming could make snowstorms more severe."

Names? Papers? Dates and predictions?

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by ugh on Monday February 14, 2011 @05:32AM (#2216235)
It’s a newspaper article. Those don’t come with citations and never have. To expect them is just crazy.
Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by jameskilton on Sunday February 13, 2011 @06:49PM (#2214518)
This is why people are using the term "global weirding" or just "climate change" instead. Yes, the Earth actually is warming. The average temperature of the entire Earth is going up. If you've taken elementary Math you'll understand that if an average increases that means the extremes of the dataset have gotten more extreme (more extreme colds, more extreme heat).

How we came to be a society that views science, logic, and rational thought as the enemy of social progression I'll never know. I'm sure there's money in it somewhere.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by gnaritas on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:01PM (#2214574)
> If you've taken elementary Math you'll understand that if an average increases that means the extremes of the dataset have gotten more extreme (more extreme colds, more extreme heat).

Um, no, it doesn't. It's perfectly possible to raise the average and reduce the extremes. You can tell nothing about the variation in a dataset from the average.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by amock on Sunday February 13, 2011 @06:55PM (#2214543)
An increasing average does not mean that the extremes are more extreme. That's a possibility but definitely not a certainty and it could easily be the case that neither extreme changes while the average varies arbitrarily close to them.
Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by anon2345 on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:02PM (#2214577)
Climate change is not logical nor is it scientific, whatever happens is construed as evidence of 'climate change'. There's no falsifiable hypothesis.
Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by ugh on Monday February 14, 2011 @05:35AM (#2216240)
If average (!) temperatures don’t increase over the next few decades (!), climate change is falsified. Easy as that.
Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by nika on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:40PM (#2214691)
Since the end of the last solar peak, the planet has been getting cooler. Since the end of the last ice age, the planet has been getting warmer. You can argue whatever direction you want by picking the dates.

We came to be a society that views science, logic and rational thought as the enemy of progress because we started letting political ideology substitute for science. It seems a political figure (in this case Al Gore) making the claim plus political bodies putting out junk science (in this case the IPCC) is all the "proof" that is needed to close off from discussion the possibility that it isn't happening for people ideologically predisposed to believe in it. I understand this tendency because I've recognized in myself belief in things that I later realized I couldn't prove.

These people are a major political movement in the USA and other parts of the world that sees themselves as having a monopoly on science, reason, logic and rationality, and which believes that their opponents are religious and evil, and therefore, -- quite ironically-- seems to feel that proof, data, argument and science are not necessary. All that seemingly is necessary to this movement is their conviction that this effect is happening. A conviction bolstered by being able to easily point to political propaganda that supports the claim, but that is not scientific. Of course, when one questions the claims made on such sites, the proponents insist that the sites represent "science" and the "deniers" are nobody to question them. (which is argument from authority, and I believe argument from false authority, both logical fallacies.)

This makes actual scientific discussion essentially impossible. Look at your post, you made several claims and did so in the tone of it being obvious that what you say is right and consequently anyone who doesn't agree is being irrational.

Do you think that glaciers, on the balance are receding or advancing? What ever your opinion, why do you believe it? Because you saw an article somewhere? Or have you reviewed the changes in the length of a statistical sample of glaciers? Actually, do you know how many glaciers make a statistical sample? I don't- I'm not trying to trick you. But if you don't know, how can you know if a study that counted that many is valid?

But you're right about one thing. There is money in it. More importantly, control. The politicians want more control, they always do, and cap & trade, CO2 reduction and all these proposals for laws all result in more control. That control is easy to turn into money- just threaten to tighten the screws on whatever industry you want to make a "donation".

Al Gore stands to become a multi-billionaire if cap & trade passes and the business he set up for trading carbon credits turns into a real business. Imagine having a near monopoly on intrinsically worthless contracts that suddenly get a lot of value under government regulation, and of course who can trade them and how is also subject to government regulation.

I have skepticism about global warming, but I haven't seen enough quality data to reach a conclusion. But I am tired, and I am irritated that I've never seen a global warming advocate who could provide quality data either, yet massive numbers of people believe this, based on political ideology and propaganda, near as I can tell.

I'm sure you were sincere in your belief that a higher average means for greater extremes. It kinda sounds like it is a logical conclusion, right? More energy in the system therefore wider variation, right? But it is not scientific, to make the argument requires a hell of a lot more than saying "if you've taken elementary math", which is a mean thing to say if you think about it, right?

How many glaciers makes a statistical sample? Serious question.

Edit: I tried several times to edit this to make it more concise, but failed miserably, alas.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by viggity on Sunday February 13, 2011 @06:48PM (#2214513)
Everything can't be proof of global warming. The climate is not getting "weirder". The weather is the weather; It is intrinsically random.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870442220457613...

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by rblion on Sunday February 13, 2011 @06:53PM (#2214530)
I don't think everything is proof of 'global warming'. I honestly don't how much is in our hands and how much isn't.

Interesting article. I like what he wrote... "That's not to say we're helpless. There is at least one climate lesson that we can draw from the recent weather: Whatever happens, prosperity and preparedness help."

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by cletus on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:17PM (#2214622)
Global warming pisses me off because it isn't so much science as it is religion.

Whether it gets hotter, colder, drier, wetter or whatever some will take that to be "proof" of global warming just as others will claim the opposite.

The really offensive thing to me is the science part. Papers that don't provide facts or, in some cases, sources for their facts, publications that give such shoddy work a free pass because it happens to agree with their editorial stance. Organizations that go out of their say to smear and silence skeptics. The list goes on.

Whatever the case climate models have a pretty poor track record when it comes to making predictions.

Last month I saw something about climate on Discovery. It was talking about "Snowball Earth", the period nearly 600 million years ago when ice extended to the equator. The show claimed that we could trigger such an event. What's more, snow and ice reflect sunlight that could cause a (excuse the pun) snowball effect: as the ice grows it gets colder.

What many seem to forget are two things:

1. What they're describing is called a divergent system. We don't live in such a system because, if we did, the earth would've either frozen solid or boiled away in the last 4 billion years and we wouldn't be here; and

2. The earth is an incredibly complex system with many interplaying variables such that making predictions and identifying cause and effect is incredibly hard.

They way I see it, the pro-AGW crowd need to:

1. Prove the earth is warming. This is far from fact. For one, it depends on your point of reference. Compared to 1890 it's warmer and for this reason the link to the Industrial Revolution and fossil fuels likes to be drawn but what about 500 years ago? 5000? 5 million? The earth has been an awful lot hotter than it is now.

2. that warming is man-made;

3. That warming is bad. It'd be bad for some but I guarantee you it'd be good for others.

4. Human intervention can alter the result;

5. That cost isn't prohibitive.

as far as I'm concerned we haven't even settled (1) yet.

In the meantime those that raise such questions are demonized. Those that benefit from offending industries aren't the least bit interested in the truth either. Instead of science we have politics and religion.

But I for one am sick of hearing that whatever happens is somehow proof of global warming.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by jamesrcole on Monday February 14, 2011 @12:54AM (#2215497)
> Global warming pisses me off because it isn't so much > science as it is religion.

I agree that there's a lot of problems with the way people talk and argue about it, but I think it needs to be clearer that this is a separate issue from whether human-made global warming is happening or not, and if it is, how severe a problem it is.

People could be arguing for it in very dodgy ways, and it could still be true.

> They way I see it, the pro-AGW crowd need to: [...] > 3. That warming is bad. It'd be bad for some but I > guarantee you it'd be good for others.

You're implying that any good effects balance out any bad ones, but of course they're unlikely to be equal in magnitude. Maybe the bad effects will be far greater than the good effects, or maybe the good effects will be greater than the bad ones - either way, it's the overall consequences that matter.

Also, I don't think the requirement should be for people to prove these things, in the sense of some absolute proof, whereby if we can't prove it definitely is happening we should act as if it is definitely not happening. In reality we always have to act in terms of our degrees of confidence about what is probably going on.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by ugh on Monday February 14, 2011 @05:36AM (#2216242)
You should really read scientific papers and not get your information about climate change from TV shows …
Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by nika on Monday February 14, 2011 @11:14PM (#2220118)
I find it amazing that global warming proponents who, frankly, never seem to know anything about the actual science are so snide whenever they encounter someone who does know the science and who points out holes.

If science really were on your side, you could make scientific claims, instead you just attack him.

This is proof that you reject science, and that you are defending a religious belief.

Re:Yes, Global Warming Could Mean More Snow by nika on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:44PM (#2214701)
You reference the snowball earth, and I'd like to point out (or emphasize) the opposite applies as well. Many times in the past (as I understand it) CO2 levels have been dramatically higher than they are today. If a runaway greenhouse effect was likely triggered by these tiny increases in CO2 (as proportion of atmosphere) claimed by proponents of AGW, wouldn't it have been triggered in the past, when CO2 levels were vastly higher?

Two opposite situations that one could plausibly argue would result in a runaway effect to an extreme equilibrium where humans couldn't survive.

They both sound plausible, but despite having experienced both ice ages and dramatically higher CO2 (and temperatures) in the past, the predictions have not happened.