Re:American Kids Aren't Getting Dumber; They Were Just Never...
by jacques_chester on Sunday February 13, 2011 @06:04PM
(#2214338)
> By definition, the position that there are significant differences between different races is racism.
Actually, the definition is believing that the differences are large enough to render some races superior to others. It's a political belief, not a biological statement.
Re:American Kids Aren't Getting Dumber; They Were Just Never...
by nitrogen on Sunday February 13, 2011 @06:17PM
(#2214405)
The concept is occasionally, regrettably, extended to include any mention that there may be performance differences between races at all, regardless of whether that comes from genetics, culture, or oppression. "Culturism," it seems, is often mistaken for racism.
Re:American Kids Aren't Getting Dumber; They Were Just Never...
by philwelch on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:56PM
(#2214735)
It's not a technical term in the slightest, so there is no exact definition; we have to go by common usage. Most people would class the statement "blacks, as a population, have lower scientifically measurable intelligence than whites" as a racist statement, despite that statement being purely biological in and of itself. Hence, racism is not merely a political belief.
I hope all people everywhere know better than to accept anyone's conclusions without serious corroboration or fact-checking. Yes, Sailer's conclusions are racist--but the question is whether they're true or not. And if you're willing to stop short at identifying them as racist without even asking that question, perhaps Sailer isn't the only one with a clear, ideological bias.
Ideological biases usually manifest themselves as flawed arguments that some conclusion or other is true. This is the type of bias you accuse Sailer of; I think your accusation is perfectly reasonable. Sometimes, though, ideological biases manifest themselves as social taboos. When that happens, everyone comfortably forgets about the question of truth or falsity and dismisses ideas out of hand simply for broaching the taboo. (See: pg, "What You Can't Say": http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html)
I'm not arguing for or against anyone's conclusions here, just suggesting some reasonable ground rules for rational conversation.