News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by saturdaysaint on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:31AM (#2212616)
Do we really need a deep conspiracy theory angle to explain the deprecation of a horribly lagging OS (Symbian) and a next-gen OS whose development was severely lagging even behind WP7?

The board brought on Elop to do precisely what he did - any ire should be directed squarely at them.

Say what you will about RIMM, at least they aren't striking at the prospect of QNX replacing their OS.

Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by bergie on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:35AM (#2212622)
It looks like even the previous gen (Maemo) of the next gen (MeeGo) has sold better than WP7
Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by jeswin on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:11AM (#2212675)
That talks more about Nokia's brand than about Maemo or Meego. I was among the first to buy a Maemo device, the hardware rocked but the software was average.

As Nokia said, it is a war of eco-systems now; not devices. Even a low-end Android beats a better spec'ed Nokia because the software is so much better. The quality of apps on Ovi store says it all.

Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by Geee on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:38AM (#2212711)
Yup, and now they totally gave up in the ecosystem wars giving their portion to Microsoft. Dumb move considering the market leader position (still over 30% with Symbian), brand loyalty, and huge mass of devoted developers. Technology pieces were falling in place with the newly announced Qt support on Ovi Store apps. There's no way someone thinks this deal was good for Nokia.
Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by jeswin on Sunday February 13, 2011 @09:19AM (#2212764)
Technology pieces were falling in place with the newly announced Qt support on Ovi Store apps?

Really? The Ovi Store is pathetic, and even though they have improved a bit recently it comes nowhere close to the other platforms. Casual games are very important, Ovi has less to offer than the nascent Windows Marketplace.

I am among the few who think this is better for Nokia, given the alternative. Nokia is a hardware company. They don't do great software, and they just accepted that fact.

Btw, they might have a gotten a good deal with Microsoft too, given the situation MS itself is in. WP7 is a great OS, and the collaboration with Nokia could see it appearing on cheaper devices. Nokia is famous for making affordable devices that can survive a drop or two. In fact, I know many people who WANT a Nokia with a decent OS.

Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by callumjones on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:41AM (#2212632)
Probably because QNX is a lot more mature. MeeGo seemed like a side project/hobby.
Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by saturdaysaint on Sunday February 13, 2011 @09:45AM (#2212829)
I'm comparing QNX more to WP7 (both OSes being brought in from the outside when internal development couldn't keep up with the competition).
Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by callumjones on Sunday February 13, 2011 @09:58AM (#2212858)
The thing is QNX alone was never the solution to RIM's problem, it's just a powerful OS. RIM did take a good look at itself and use other purchases and in house talent to build a pretty amazing UI on top of QNX.
Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by siika2000 on Sunday February 13, 2011 @11:55AM (#2213146)
There's no need for conspiracy theories, but this is something that should not be overlooked either. Elop's decisions influence two very large companies and their shareholders, and one small to medium sized country and its taxpayers. One thing is to make sure that his actions are legal (which they appear to be, unsurprisingly), and other is to understand the context and biases he is operating with.
Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by mtw on Sunday February 13, 2011 @07:58AM (#2212651)
The partnership is still suspicious; any reasonable person would tell you Nokia should have picked Android instead. There's no competitive advantage picking up WP7, unless microsoft wanted to subsidize every nokia handset
Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by saturdaysaint on Sunday February 13, 2011 @09:04AM (#2212741)
"Any reasonable person" Careful - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoning_the_well

There are serious competitive considerations for Nokia not choosing Android. I think Elop outlines them pretty intelligently here - http://video.allthingsd.com/video/nokia-ceo-on-choosing-wind...

Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by rst on Sunday February 13, 2011 @12:11PM (#2213184)
It's interesting to see him acknowledge directly that his personal familiarity with Microsoft played a role in the decision (at about 1:00 in). But aside from that, well... opinions differ. At about 3:15, he said that the danger if they went with Android is:

1) The platform would succeed.

2) They'd be one among a crowd of Android phone manufacturers.

3) It would be hard to differentiate from the others.

Contrast that to Windows Phone 7, where:

1) The platform is playing catch-up, and may fail entirely.

2) They're already one among a crowd of Windows Phone manufacturers, with LG, Samsung and HTC already shipping, and Dell having devices in the pipeline.

3) The party that controls the platform has chosen not to allow differentiation, requiring all the devices to be lookalikes[1].

On all his supposed drawbacks of Android, WP7 looks even worse.

There's some other odd stuff in the video, which begs for explanation. He starts by saying that "Microsoft has placed a large bet on us." But it isn't yet obvious why Microsoft has bet more on Nokia's success than it has on the success of the other WP7 handset manufacturers. And if they have, I can't imagine HTC or Samsung being happy about it.

There's also some stuff at about 2:30 about how each party has licensed technology from the other, with an implication (though not an outright statement) that money might be flowing both ways. If that's true, it raises the possibility that the sale of an HTC WP7 handset results in royalty payments to Nokia, for the mapping technology that Microsoft has licensed. That could cause real friction with the other vendors.

(To clarify: the mapping technology bit was part of the announcement, though it wasn't clear what it was doing there; the payment structures were not announced, but Elop did seem to imply in that video that money would be going both ways, and I'm not sure what other reason there is that Microsoft would have to write checks to Nokia.)

[1] http://mobilementalism.com/2011/02/12/the-photo-the-nokia-fa... has a photo (second in the post) with a bunch of them. They all really do look alike.

Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by jsnell on Sunday February 13, 2011 @12:30PM (#2213230)
> I'm not sure what other reason there is that Microsoft would have to write checks to Nokia.

Microsoft is already in the habit of paying companies to force their users to use Bing search (see Verizon replacing Google search with Bing on some of their Android phones).

Though for Nokia's sake I hope they're not getting paid per use but per device. Bing's quality outside the US is dreadful, so the vast majority of Nokia's customers are either getting a crappy experience or will somehow need to replace the default search engine.

Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by rbanffy on Sunday February 13, 2011 @09:53AM (#2212847)
> unless microsoft wanted to subsidize every nokia handset

I wouldn't discard that possibility. Phone makers have to pay to call their Android sets Android and to have the Gmail, Google Maps and other Google properties on their phones. Maybe Microsoft is giving them a boatload of money and saying "spend this money to make WP7 suck less, for we can't to it ourselves" on the condition they sell only WP7 phones.

We don't know what's in the package. This could give Nokia time enough so it can be carved into smaller sellable pieces before the whole thing collapses.

The whole thing would collapse anyway without an aggressive course correction. MeeGo isn't going anywhere and Symbian is doomed. They could have gone Android, but I guess the board thinks the company is doomed no matter what is done and that WP7 is what brings it more time.

Re:Stephen Elop is the 7th biggest individual shareholder of... by jarek on Sunday February 13, 2011 @09:47AM (#2212836)
It's funny how people pick on Windows Desktop and Android for setting off a race to the bottom among manufacturers and then say there is no competitive advantage when one manufacturer chooses something else.