News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House: What's Blocking Innovation in America? My A... by baddox on Saturday February 12, 2011 @07:57PM (#2211698)
> For example, no startup could hope to survive without laws protecting trade secrets.

Existing theft and trespassing laws already outlaw unauthorized physical access to your property. As for disgruntled or opportunistic employees, you can utilize existing contract law to ensure their doing so is illegal. What exactly do trade secret laws cover that aren't covered by more reasonable and fundamental laws?

> Open source is no exception. It relies heavily on rules of copyright law and on licensing to make its system work. If everything were freely shareable without any form of restriction, one does not have open source - one has freeware.

That's why I have strong feelings that the free software movement, or at least the GPL, is insanely contradictory. Their claim is that there shouldn't be liberty restrictions placed on software, but what they really mean is there should be different liberty restrictions placed on software, specifically the ones they happen to like more. In my opinion, software isn't really free unless it's in the public domain (or, nearly equivalently, if there were no longer any intellectual property protection for software).

Most of your points are simply that removing the various forms of intellectual property protection would harm some people. The validity of your specific examples are variously debatable, but even if you're right, I don't think that's a good enough argument for keeping the laws around. I can't conceive of any legal modification that wouldn't harm someone. In my opinion, even if something might harm startups (and I'm certainly not convinced that IP laws are vital to startups), that's not a sufficient argument.

Re:White House: What's Blocking Innovation in America? My A... by tptacek on Sunday February 13, 2011 @12:09AM (#2212124)
If I break into your office, steal your secret source code, and give a copy to my brother, what part of "existing theft and trespassing laws" prevent him from selling that copy to the highest bidder?
Re:White House: What's Blocking Innovation in America? My A... by jberryman on Sunday February 13, 2011 @12:55AM (#2212204)
> Their claim is that there shouldn't be liberty restrictions placed on software, but what they really mean is there should be different liberty restrictions placed on software, specifically the ones they happen to like more.

Of course there are different takes on this issue, but you make it sound as thought the GPL is a conspiracy by Stallman. The FOSS ecosystem encompasses a wide array of types of and takes on "freedom" and there is a place for all the different licenses developers can choose from to open source their code.

Re:White House: What's Blocking Innovation in America? My A... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday February 12, 2011 @08:18PM (#2211736)
>As for disgruntled or opportunistic employees, you can utilize existing contract law to ensure their doing so is illegal.

The current laws include some protections for the individual inventor/creator which would be wiped out by this sort of thing. For example (in Europe at least) fair compensation for an inventor even when their work is covered as "work for hire".